Topper Copies

Critically Analyze Hannah Arendt's view on ideology. (10 Marks)

Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025

Hannah Arendt is a heterodox thinker, who with her 'thinking without barriers' has given her views on ideology in book on utilitarianism.

Arendt is 20th century philosopher, a contemporary of Hitler & totalitarian world. Before Arendt, the ideology that started as scientific study of 'ideas' by Tracy, was called as 'false consciousness' by Marx in German ideology'.

However, it was later marxists views such as Lenin, Gramsci, Lukacs who believed that even working class needs an 'ideology', liberals as Arendt & Popper give liberal view of ideology.

Arendt argues that ideology & terror combine to make a totalitarian state.

More than terror, it is ideology that plays major role as it legitimises the use of terror. Superfluous masses (crackpots) who have lost critical reasoning & spirit of enquiry fall prey to this ideology, They believe these false fabrications as true, These atomised men, 'mass', under ideology end public sphere & totalitarianism begins.

Her views that ideology is false propaganda of totalitarian state is countered by sociological view of Karl Mannheim who argues that all ideologies are from perspective of a particular class, one is ideology (of dominant class) & other is utopia (of subordinate class).

Oakeshott argues that political science is "bottomless & borderless sea" & no one ideology can explain it.