Analyse Kymlicka's theory of multicultural citizenship. (10 Marks)
Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025
Will Kymlicka in his book 'multicultural citizenship' has given his criticism for universal citizenship model of rights followed by liberal western societies.
He argues for 'multicultural citizenship' instead of 'one-size-fit-all' approach of universal rights. Multicultural citizenship would give rights to people according to their culture specifications.
For Kymlicka, a particular minority group with a specific culture must be given -
a) self-determination rights, self-governance rights, such as V, VI schedule in India for tribal communities b) special representative rights for their representation at central bodies (legislature) such as India's reservation c) Special ethnic & cultural rights for preservation of culture, such as Article 29,30 in Indian constitution.
Kymlicka's concept is criticised by Bhikhu Parekh in 'Rethinking Multiculturalism' as Kymlicka while giving multicultural rights to nationals, ignores refugees and immigrants. Parekh argues culture is important for all & thus favours rights to all.
Feminists like Marion Iris Young have too focused on 'differentiated citizenship' for women & proposes affirmative action by state to give differential equality to equalise the differences'.
Present globalised world must incorporate multiculturalism, as seen in Canada (1st multicultural state officially).