Topper Copies

Critically Evaluate the significance of Rawls concept of veil of ignorance. (10 Marks)

Priyanka Choudhary, AIR 79, 2025

Rawls transformed the liberal theory of justice which was dominated by Utilitarian principle of 'greatest happiness with greatest number' with his "egalitarian" view of justice.

Rawls gives a procedural theory of distributive justice rather than end state theory. He presupposes Kantian men who will come together to decide distribution of primary goods and these men are under veil of ignorance & in their original position.

Veil of ignorance is significant as this helps Rawls create a 'rational but ignorant man' who knows general fact but no particular fact about oneself.

This ignorance helps man go for 'maximin' approach and think from different perspectives of different classes. This way they come up with social contract that values both liberty, equality & difference principle to help least advantaged.

While veil of ignorance helps Rawls integrate liberty & equality, it is criticised for being impractical. Communitarians argue that man can never be in original position under veil of ignorance.

Nozick (neo-liberal) has given entitlement theory of justice criticising Rawls' view & veil of ignorance as theory that favours one class over another, as end state theory.

Rawls, however, has revived liberalism & is the greatest philosophers of 20th century! (Bill Clinton)