कर के वितरण को लेकर दक्षिणी राज्यों की आपत्तियाँ भारत की संघीय संरचना में निहित गहरे संकटों की ओर इशारा करती हैं, जिसे आगामी परिसीमन प्रक्रिया और भी जटिल बना सकती है। आलोचनात्मक परीक्षण कीजिए। The objection of Southern states over tax devolution alludes to broader challenges in India's federal structure, exacerbated by the impending delimitation exercise. Critically Examine.
Apurva Verma, AIR 42, 2025
Federalism is defined as the rule differentiation of centre and state guarenteed by the constitution. India is a federal nation and federalism is a part of basic structure doctrine.
The constitution has made states dependent on centre in fiscal matters as more tax yielding subjects are with the centre. Post implementation of GST in 2017, the share of state government have further got reduced and have [illegible] been made dependant on centre for devolution.
The successive Finance Commissions have suggested to improve shares of state government but the devolution has not been upto the mark. Further, the criteria considered by FC including income distance goes against Southern Indian states who have done well to control their population and improved standard of living.
Untimely devolution is again a matter of concern because in the mechanism of cooperative federalism, good governance becomes a core objective and states being close to people have more responsibility to implement measures for universal public good.
Recent examples includes states like Kerala, Tamilnadu and West Bengal bringing suit against central government under original jurisdiction of SC. This increasing tension further exacerbates the issue of imbalance in fiscal wheel.
Post 2026, the freezing applied to expansion of constituencies through delimitation is again a cause of tussle between centre and state. If applied proportionally to population; states who have performed better in population control and aligned their policies for public good will be at loss. They will face the consequences of controlled population in comparison to unsustainable population of BIMARU states. These BIMARU states will further have enhanced representation in legislatures and will result in policies which are more population-driven rather than development-driven agenda of Southern states.
We need to utilise platforms like inter-State council, national development council to iron out the differences regarding fiscal federalism and delimitation for presenting a united front against poverty and underdevelopment.