Topper Copies

भारत का सर्वोच्च न्यायालय, जो 75 वर्ष पूर्व संवैधानिक परियोजना का एक केंद्रीय भाग बना, क्या वह संविधान निर्माताओं की न्याय संबंधी अपेक्षाओं पर खरा उतर सका है? अपने तर्क प्रस्तुत कीजिए तथा तथ्यों से पुष्ट कीजिए। The Supreme Court of India was established more than 75 years ago as a core part of India's constitutional project. Do you think the court has been able to live up to the ideals of justice imagined by the framers of the Constitution? Give arguments in favour of your points, and substantiate them with empirical facts.

Apurva Verma, AIR 42, 2025

The Supreme Court of India established under Part-V of the constitution is the supreme authority regarding constitutional provisions and sentinel qui vive regarding fundamental rights.

The SC was not imagined as a passive judiciary. It was created with the intent of being active participant in India's social revolution through the constitution. It is the supreme authority to defend rights of the common citizens against arbitrary legislative and executive excesses.

As the Preamble mentions justice - social, economical and political, SC has from time to time tried to uphold value of justice by safeguarding rights of citizens. Post imposition of emergency in 1975, it became more assertive of its role. The Minerva Mills case, 1980 reaffirmed limitations of Basic Structure doctrine limiting the scope of constituent power of Parliament.

In the domain of upholding fundamental rights, SC expanded the scope of Article-21 bringing in the element of due process of law. This has led to better protection of citizen rights. In times of policy paralysis, SC has come to the forefront filling the vacuum as can be seen in the form of Vishakha Guidelines, upholding rights of Dongria Kondh tribes in Odisha against POSCO, affidavit requirement to counter criminalisation of politics.

However, in terms of human rights SC's record has been average. Be it the imposition of AFSPA in North east & Jammu & Kashmir or use of parliamentary privileges against journalists, SC needs to play a more assertive role.

Overall SC has been a defender of fundamental rights and has kept the constitution working by it's innovative judicial principles.