Topper Copies

"भारतीय राज्य ने हमेशा गहरे सामाजिक-आर्थिक परिवर्तन की आकांक्षाओं और ऊर्जा को कृत्रिम सहमति और समन्वयी राजनीति के माध्यम से सीमित करने का प्रयास किया है।" — फ्रांसिन फ्रेंकल। आलोचनात्मक परीक्षण कीजिए। "The Indian state has always tried to delimit the aspirations of and energy for radical socio-economic changes through a fabricated consensus and accommodative politics." — Francine Frankel. Critically examine.

Apurva Verma, AIR 42, 2025

Indian political and social landscape has been marred by a number of mass movements. The recent farmer's protest against farm Bills highlight how "states function on the basis of consent."

According to Marxist scholars, state is a Bonapast, i.e it rules by manufacturing consent and bargaining between different sections. The role of bureaucrats become important in this regard.

India continues to carry the legacy of post-colonialism and suffers from a number of challenges like lack of substantive democracy, criminalisation of politics, curbs on freedom of speech and expression, jobless growth.

These problems have resulted in coming of masses together as "Anomic Groups". One example in social domain is the Nirbhaya gangrape outrage. However, state which had been reluctant to bring stricter laws was reflexive enough to constitute Justice Verma Committee and police arm of state was able to take quick action.

Other social uprising includes democratic upsurges of sci. state went for co-option. If we go by Gramsci, state not only rules by use of coercive power but relies on hegemony by sometimes giving ears to the demand of people.

The 2013 India Against corruption social upheaval was tackled with enactment of Lokpal and Lokayukta Act. However, post the coming of law, it's implementation has been in jeopardy after many posts being vacant.

Quoting Marxist scholars, there is a need for continuous revolution which is however tackled by state's flexibility and hegemony.