क्या आप इस मत से सहमत हैं कि जब तक न्यायालयों की सार्थक भूमिका बनी नहीं रहती, तब तक नौकरशाही और कॉर्पोरेट जगत पर्यावरण की रक्षा हेतु आगे नहीं आएंगे? भारत में पर्यावरण आंदोलन में सर्वोच्च न्यायालय की भूमिका का आलोचनात्मक मूल्यांकन कीजिए। Do you agree with the view that unless the salutary role of the courts is in place, there is no guarantee that bureaucracy and corporations would rise to the occasion to protect the environment? Critically evaluate the role of the Supreme Court in the environmental movement in India.
Apurva Verma, AIR 42, 2025
India has a long history of environmental movements, starting from the war waged by tribal revolts against colonial british government. Post-independence, Chipko movement was the tipping point.
The constitution of India mentions about environment and its conservation both in the fundamental rights under Article-21 and DPSP. Even Fundamental duty mentions it as a priority.
Supreme court has been at the forefront of promoting environmentalism. Considering the shallow ecology, term used by Sumita Narain to distinguish environmentalism for consumption in India; SC followed a community-environment approach.
Post the Bhopal Gas tragedy, in 1984, SC in MC Mehta vs UoI gave the "right to safe environment" as a fundamental right. In 1991, even changes were made in the civil liability laws due to the strict approach of SC. In this instance, we can see the failure on part of bureaucracy and corporation who played the role of safeguarding their own interest, reinforcing the concept of "environmental State" given by [illegible names].
With the turn of century, Indian government brought a number of laws safeguarding the environment. - Panchayat Extension to Scheduled Area, 1996 - Biodiversity Act, 2002 - Forest Rights Act, 2006 - Right to information Act - Environment Impact Assessment
SC has given a humane interpretation to these laws empowering people. The establishment of NGT has been an addition to increasing role of SC and judiciary.
However, sometimes the role of SC has been detrimental for national interest. Eg: Stopping of functioning of coal mines post Coal scam resulting in heavy pressure on public purse.
Further, instruments like Corporate Social Responsibility, Environmental Social Governance and overhaul of bureaucracies with schemes like Mission-Karamyogi has resulted in positive impacts. The mindset of bureaucracy and corporates has changed towards contribution in national development.
The role of all the players including SC, bureaucracy and corporates is essential for true environmentalism. We can take cue from Rousseau who has reminded "Even the strongest man is not strong enough."