Critically assess whether the current model of Panchayati Raj in India is compatible with the principle of participatory democracy or has it devolved into a mechanism of mere formal decentralisation?
Rakhi, AIR 65, 2025
Panchayati Raj was established by 73rd Amendment Act of 1992 by recommendation of Gadgil committee of 1986, resulting in 3 tier government at gram sabha, towns and district levels with mandatory elections every five years.
The success of Panchayati Raj can be shown in the regular holding of elections and the devolution of more funds, with autonomy in decision making on nature of revenue mobilisation. This has resulted in participative democracy by inclusion of women by method of reservation (33%). Also, the provisions have been extended to 5th Schedule tribal areas, leading to PESA Act, 1996, resulting in grassroot participation.
However, its success has been criticised as the voluntary devolution of funds has been undertaken by only 9 states, which has empowered states more than Panchayats.
Moreover, the revenue collection by own source is only 32% as per CAG report, with reduced decentralisation in true sense. This has been exacerbated by reduced social audits, leading to lack of accountability.
The regular elections are conducted intermittently with rise in criminalisation at local level.
Moreover, the women Sarpanchs are replaced by Panchayat Patis, showing the patriarchal mindset prevalent in the society and politics.
Thus, the need is to take example from states such as Kerala who has established its own Panchayat ombudsman and carries out regular audits.
The need is to provide more power and autonomy to the Panchayats, with empowering gram Sabha, reducing discretion of states and female decentralisation as suggested by Gandhi (Oceanic Circles of Power) and 2nd ARC (Principle of Subsidiarity).