The evolution of Fundamental Rights jurisprudence in India reflects a shift from a textual to a purposive interpretation. Discuss this transformation with reference to landmark Supreme Court judgements.
Rakhi, AIR 65, 2025
Fundamental Rights were adopted in Indian constitution, with effect from 26 January 1950, with Part 3, making its Implementation enforceable, by the court of law.
This are obligation upon state to enforce, as the citizens can approach for its implementation to Supreme court under Article 32 which itself is a fundamental rights.
They ensure Civil and political rights, not only for its citizens but also some of them pertaining to the foreigners. eg Right to life.
The constitution is referred to as living document, as per Zoya Hassan and thus evolves by methods such as constitutional amendments under Article 368 and by judicial interpretations by method of judicial review, by both Supreme court as well as High court.
During the 1950's debate arose its amendability under Article 13 and its definition of laws. Supreme court included fundamental rights in definition of laws by AK Gopalan case of 1950. This was also upheld by Sajjan Singh case of 1965.
However, the first case of judicial activism emerged, when fundamental rights were considered Sacrosanct in 1967. This made their Amendment not possible under Article 368. (Gorakdan case, 1967)
The Keshav nand Bharti case of 1973, allowed for their amendments, but without changing the basic structure of constitution which resulted in its declaration of Secularism (SR Bommai case, 1994), free and fair elections (Indira Nehru case, 1975), judicial review (Minerva Mills case, 1980) as part of basic structure.
Moreover, the inclusion of various meanings to fundamental rights has evolved their extent. The Menaka Gandhi case of 1978 includes the method of 'due process by law' alongside 'Procedure established by law' for establishing right to eg life under Article 21.
Moreover, Cases such as Ranjit Singh case of 2024, has allowed for Article 21 to include right to clean for its residents.
Cases such as I.R Coelho Case of 2007 has also restricted articles under 9th schedule, by including them under judicial review, for violating fundamental rights (Article 14,19,31).
Moreover, reservation provisions have been included under Article 16 for including OBC by Indra Sawhney case of 1992. The social equality was also tried to be enforced by Subhash Mahajan Case.
Moreover, Supreme court transforms the meanings and resolution of conflicts by means of judicial review which must not be reached to judicial over-reach and high headedness, maintaining Separation of power and co-operative federalism.