Different perspectives on the Revolt of 1857
Rakhi, AIR 65, 2025
Revolt of 1857 was the first major resistance by the Indians against the British policies, such as Doctrine of lapse and racial discrimination, within the army as well as against the peasants.
The revolt had different perspectives, with some referring it as a mutiny, while others according it the status of 1st independence war.
As per Savarkar, the revolt was a first war of independence, due to the scale of its spread, ranging from Awadh, Nagpur, Delhi, Kolkata, Maharashtra, with full coordinated attacks under the common leader i.e. Bahadur Shah Zafar.
However, as per scholars such as RP Dutt, the revolt was more of a mutiny, as it was only limited to a few states, with lack of common objective and any further [?] ves. Moreover, prior to this, many such revolts had taken place such as Bivani Vellu Thampi revolt and Vellore mutiny during 1800's.
However, leaders such as Jawaharlal Nehru, chose a middle path, calling it both a mutiny and first war of independence as it was aimed at British overthrow, for the first time.
This revolt led to change in British policies, who now focussed on Divide and Rule, resulting in communalism and rise in appeasement of Muslims by Britishers (Syed Ahmed Khan).