Explain the tensions between cultural relativism and the advocacy of universal human rights in global politics.
Rakhi, AIR 65, 2025
Universal human rights refers to the rights which uphold the basic dignity of individuals, throughout the world i.e universal concept.
It was established by the declaration of UDHR in 1948 as a response to the holocaust experienced in germany under Adolf Hitler.
The human rights entails basic natural rights, which are being referred to by Locke, (eg) right to life and also rights ensuring dignity as demonstrated by Immanuel Kant, where in his "Perpetual Peace", he looks it as a way to emancipate the masses.
However, this has been contested by the cultural relativism, theory by the communitarians and multiculturalists, where traditions and culture are found basis for ensuring rights.
This has been putforth by Robert Pichman and Michael Sandel, where he described 'good' as basis to determine 'right', and against the libertarian approach of "right being prior to good".
This has been described in "complex equality" by Michael Walzer, who preferred different rights for developing societies than the western world, based on culture.
This was also referred to by Lee Kwon-Yew (Singapore PM), who was inspired by Chinese government and focus on Asian values, without imitating the west. Moreover, SE Asian nations such as Malaysia (Muthhi Mohammed) also focussed on culture as basis of governance.
India has also forwarded traditions by scholars such as TN Madan who described it as way of life and by Gandhian scholar, Ashish Nandy, in his Anti-Secularist manifesto.
Thus, Human rights' imposition has been seen by east as imposition of Westernisation by developed nations, which has also led in rise of Islamic fundamentalism (eg) 9/11 attack.
Thus, need is to respect the uniqueness, while ensuring dignity for all humans.