Topper Copies

Examine the evolution of the idea of justice from Plato to Rawls.

Rakhi, AIR 65, 2025

Justice, as a concept, finds its origin in the works of Plato, where he described it as an architectonic principle and the virtue of virtues.

According to Plato, just like an architect provides moderation to the works of a carpenter, justice shapes the values of reason, appetite and temperance in sync with each other.

For this, Plato argues the growth of virtue and knowledge, which is found in an ideal state. This ideal state has functional representation, where duties are allocated as per qualities of soul, with no interference in each other's activities. Here, justice is ensured by a philosopher king, where the king is the most virtuous man and as per Plato, no law/ordinance is mightier than knowledge, signifying justice to be achieved by rationality of the king.

This has been criticized by Aristotle, who is considered as both the disciple and critic of Plato. As per Aristotle the best form of government to ensure justice is Polity, where citizens participate and decides law ("law is reason without passion").

This helps in achieving patripatri justice and proportional justice, where equals are treated equally and unequals unequally. This gave rise to 'affirmative action' theory, promoting reservation for Marginalised.

In the transition phase, Machiavelli promoted idea of justice by the Prince, who works in national interest, which is priority for just society.

In modern times, when utility became a dominant principle, it was seen antithetical to justice. This was refuted by Mill, who prioritised quality over quantity and harm Principle for classifying unjust actions, to be enforced in a democratic form of government.

In present times, John Rawls in his Theory of Justice (1971) has revitalised the concept by focusing on veil of ignorance and initial position where citizens decide the criteria, being unaware of their actual position in real life. This leads to proportionate justice, where the greatest benefit is provided to least advantaged, by equalising their initial positions.

This has been entailed in the 'capability approach' by Amartya Sen, where he prioritised the rational choice over moral choice and justice as being a contextual. Another social liberal, Dworkin focused on endowment insensitive and ambition sensitive approach, by equalising their final position.

Thus, justice has evolved over the years, with recent nations going for social welfare policies, for providing equity as form of justice.