Topper Copies

Freebies in electoral politics have sparked debate over their impact on governance in India. Differentiate between freebies and welfare measures, and examine their impact on governance.

Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025

RBI defines freebies as social welfare measure that is give free of cost. The rise of freebies culture has resulted as new modus operandi for electoral winnability.

| Freebies | Welfare Measures | |---|---| | Freebies are for short-term measures | long term - well thought out social measures (DPSP) | | usually part of electoral populism eg free bus pass, laptop etc | They are part of long term programmes eg NFSA-, RTE-, MGNREGA etc | | Not-all welfare schemes are freebies | freebies are part of social welfare | | Impact on fiscal health is high and threatening | since these are well planned, effects are manageable |

Freebies are part of welfare, not viceversa.

The line between the two is blurring in the recent debates. Freebies can be bandaging the effects/failure of welfare measures.

Impact on Governance POSITIVES 1. Article 38 - state to secure a social order for public welfare 2. SC in Subramanium Balaji (2016) said they enforce the DPSP's 3. provide/fill the welfare vacuum 4. gender-empowerment + eco. growth => free buses => more women labour force particip ↓ ↑ GDP

NEGATIVES 1. RBI report and Niti Aayog's Fiscal Health Index (2025) - high growing debt of few states (eg) [a bar chart of debt-to-state-GDP for Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Rajasthan (75%) and Punjab (70%)] 2. free and fair elections => disrupts level playing field 3. market distortion 4. SC: creating a parasitical society -> dependency ↑ (BR Gavai)

The Supreme court in Ashwani Kumari Upadhyay (2025) is currently hearing the issue of freebies in politics. Its judgement would give further clarity and change the dynamics of fiscal prudence and electoral dynamics.