"The Upper House was envisioned as a reviewing chamber and not a rival to the Lower House." In light of this statement, do you think the Rajya Sabha continues to fulfil this vision in contemporary Indian polity?
Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025
eg of the Upper house (or) The Rajya Sabha carries out meaningful debates and discussions for most of its sitting - it has done its job" - TR Krishnamari (Member of Const. Assembly)
Not a Rival to Lok Sabha 1. If LS is a house of commons, RS is a house of reflection 2. Its role is to provide guidance and sense of responsibility to LS 3. It is not a barrier, but a platform for cooperation 4. LS has greater powers compared to RS
R.S continues to fulfill this vision 1. It adds a layer of scrutiny 2. checks hastily moved bills 3. adds to meaningful discussion eg The data protection bill 4. Represents in important parliament committee eg Public Accounts Committee 5. It act the federal equilibrium by representing interests of states eg GST Act, 2017 6. It is a house of dignity eg Nominated Members across diverse field => Sudha Murthy, Sachin Tendulkar 7. It aids in bridging the interregnum when LS is dissolved 8. During Emergencies, without LS (when dissolved) - takes needful action 9. Legislating on state items => only RS can initiate
Issues 1. less attendance of Nominated members eg S. Tendulkar 2. lack of valuable debates 3. total days of appearance attendance => very low ≤ 100 days from 150+ in 1950s 4. not rising beyond party politics 5. Removal of criteria of residence => state's interests are not well represented
Rajya Sabha - thus needs active reforms and participation. In an age where debates are rare and informed debates even rarer, the Role of Rajya Sabha is imperative in ensuring its role envisaged by the makers.