The growing number of undertrial prisoners in India reflects both systemic and procedural lapses within the criminal justice system. In light of recent Supreme Court directions, discuss the underlying challenges and suggest a multi-pronged approach to address this crisis.
Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025
According to NCRB Data (2022) the undertrial prisoners form more than 50% of the prison population, hinting at a structural and procedural lapse in our Criminal justice system (CJS)
Procedural & System lapses 1. State-wise prison manuals => lack of uniformity 2. long-drawn judicial procedure eg In our CJS, "procedure is punishment," - ex CJI N V Ramana 3. prison capacity - limited 4. stringent Bail-conditions. eg "bail is the rule, jail is an exception" - Justice Krishna Iyer 5. adjournments after adjournment => vested interests 6. lack of awareness of Rights - as highlighted by Vidhi-centre for legal research
Underlying Challenges 1. lack of adoption of alternative dispute redressal (ADR) eg Lok Adalat 2. SC guidelines are not enforced 3. changes in fundamental laws eg BNS/BNSS etc => lack of awareness and updation 4. fragmented CJS => lacks coordination b/n organs 5. very few pro-bono cases -> to take case under NALSA free legal-aid
Multi pronged Approach 1. Vineet Singh (2025) - undertrial classification based on probable sentence, if convicted 2. Hussainnara Khatoon → Right to speedy trial (Article 21) 3. Strong backing To NALSA → more resources, HR 4. AIJS - in future → lower courts have 85% of 5.9 cr pending cases (Data, Grnd SC) 5. Prison Manuals reforms → Sweden/Norway: Best practices 6. fast track Courts for undertrials only 7. Sudha Bharadwaj case (2023) - relaxing bail conditions => "default bail"
The recommendation of Malimath, Ribeiro, Mulla committee along with Prakash singh (2006) are the need of the hour