While cooperative federalism is rooted in the design of the Constitution, political considerations have given rise to competitive and confrontational federalism. Examine the role of constitutional and extra-constitutional institutions in reconciling these trends within India's federal structure.
Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025
Article 01 - says India is a 'union of states' and Granville Austin calls Indian federalism as a cooperative federalism' - which is sui-generis (Alexandrowicz)
Coop. fed rooted in design of I.Const 1. 7th schedule (Article 246) 2. Rajya sabha - voice of states 3. Finance Commission (A. 280) 4. taxation powers 5. Doctrine of territorial nexus - state supreme in their spheres 6. Interstate Council (Art.262) 7. River water dispute (Art. 261)
Political considerations hurting cooperative federalism 1. Transfer of state items into concurrent list (Art. 246) - 42nd CAA 2. partisan role of gubernatorial office - eg stalling state bills 3. centre's control over Residuary list (A. 248) 4. Centre's encroaching into state's jurisdiction eg Rajendra Shah (2021) - Multi-state cooperative Act. 5. GST compensation cess - delays -> despite losing in taxing powers 6. Reduction in net proceedings sharing by FC -> 42% to 41%. 7. delimitation issue - North South divide over population control vs. seat allocation 8. Three language formula - withholding of PM-SHRI funds.
Role of extra Const. and Const. bodies 1. Article 263 - Interstate Council - platform for assuaging the fears of state govt. 2. Zonal Councils - headed by Home Minister - regional interests 3. GST Council -> Mohit Minerals case (2023) -> states are on equal pedestal as Centre 4. NITI Aayog - Team India spirit through coop. and competitive fed.
Issues with these bodies 1. ISC has met twice in last 6 years 2. partisan role of NITI Aayog 3. non-binding recommendation of ISC/zonal council
Federalism is a part of basic structure (SR Bommai/1994). Coop- and competitive federalism are not confrontational and combative federalism is the way forward