The evolving relationship between Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles of State Policy has been a dynamic feature of India's constitutional journey, often necessitating judicial interventions and constitutional amendments. Discuss.
Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025
Fundamental Rights (Article 12-35) and Directive principles (Article 36 to 51) of Part III & IV of Indian Constitution form the core of political-civil and social-economic rights (2-gen. of rights - Karel Vasak)
Dynamic relationship between the DPSP and FRs 1. FRs are justifiable in nature through article 32/226, whereas DPSP are not 2. FR ensure political democracy where DPSP - socio-economic democracy 3. Ambedkar said: political democracy with socio-economic dem at its base is meaningless => thus, this relation is ensured 4. In Champakam Dorairajan (1951) - SC said FRs cannot be sacrificed for the implementation of DPSP 5. The 24th and 39th CAA, established supremacy of Article 39(b)/(c) over article 14 and 19 6. In Kesavananda Bharati (1973) SC said the extention to all directive principles over Art. 14 & 19 as null & void 7. In Minerva Mills (1980) -> SC: restored the doctrine of Harmonious Construction -> balance b/n the two is part of the basic structure 8. Waman Rao - Called DPSP and FRs as two wheels of the chariot, however, FR >> DPSP, as they are justifiable 9. In NM Thomas C/s UoI, SC said they are not antagonistic to each other and state reconcile the two 10. 86th Amendment (2002) - Right to education both-a DPSP and FR (Article 21A) - balancing both 11. Courts through PIL and judicial activism has balanced DPSP-FR eg Access to justice (Art. 39A) is a fundamental Right Art (21) 12. similarly, Right to health, shelter livelihood, clean air, wages etc eg Olga Tellis, MC Mehta, property owners case (2024)
In K.C. [?] case, SC said FR and DSP form the core conscience of the constitution. To balance the two is to realise the aspirations of the founding fathers. Const. amendments and judiciary has maintained the fine balance.