The role of Governors in opposition-ruled States has been a flashpoint in Centre-State relations. Critically discuss how gubernatorial overreach challenges the position of state governments and suggest safeguards to mitigate such conflicts
Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025
Article 163 of the Indian Constitution provides for Governor to every state as its executive head, he acts as the bridge b/n the centre and state and Sarkaria Commission calls Governor as the lynchpin.
Flashpoint in centre-state Relations 1. Recent, TN Governor and state over the assent of bills (13 bills) 2. curtailing of Governor's address by TN governor 3. misuse of discretionary powers 4. WB governor - defamation case against CM 5. LG of Delhi vs Chief Minister of Delhi
Gubernatorial overreach challenging state 1. disruption of exercising legislative mandate eg 13 bills - withheld by TN Gov. 2. disruption of day to day administration eg LG of Delhi 3. not acting timely on the pardoning powers (Art. 213) eg AG Perarivalan 4. acts as the agent of central govt. - undermining state's efforts 5. Nabam Rebia - governor without the guidance of Council of Ministers called the state assembly 6. sitting on VC's appointments eg Kerala Ambedkar university 7. misuse of 201 article - referring to President
Safeguards 1. Punchhi Commission - consulting state gov i.e CM before appointment 2. Venkatachaliah Comm (2002) -> governor should be man of outstanding integrity above politics 3. Nabam Rebia (2016) - Governor's actions cannot be arbitrary, whimsical & capricious 4. Samsher Singh case - Governor is a office subordinate to President / central govt 5. Soli Sorabjee in "Governor - Sage or Saboteur" - governor's discretionary are limited; his actions should be actuated by good faith and tempered by caution
Thus, governor's position should be reformed to call for greater cooperation between centre & states.