Topper Copies

After being posted as the District Development Officer (DDO) in a district dominated by tribal villages, I met with all the Block Development Officers (BDOs) to understand the region's specific problems. The primary issues identified were water scarcity, poor educational infrastructure, irregularities in the midday meal scheme, and non-existent roads. With a limited budget, I began planning solutions for these pressing problems. A few weeks after the BDOs meeting, I made a courtesy visit to the Superintendent of Police's (SP) office. During our cordial conversation, the SP mentioned witchcraft-related crimes, which surprised me as none of the BDOs had brought it up. My concern grew knowing that most victims of these crimes were women. A week later, while visiting a block for a routine inspection, I met with school teachers, ASHA workers, and women elders from Self-Help Groups (SHGs). Through discussions, I learned that witchcraft had deep roots in the community. ASHA workers reported incidents almost every month, though none were officially recorded. Realising the gravity of the situation, I decided to allocate part of the development funds to tackle witchcraft-related superstitions. Local NGOs and SHGs welcomed the initiative, but two weeks later, you received an RTI wanting an explanation for allocating funds for witchcraft-related issues at the cost of critical areas like education, roads, and water supply. (a) What are the issues involved in the above case? (b) With a limited budget at your disposal, you decide to allocate funds to tackle witchcraft-related superstitions. How would you justify your decision to the community and stakeholders? (c) Given that witchcraft-related crimes were not initially reported by the BDOs, how would you address this lack of communication and ensure better reporting and transparency moving forward?

Diksha Rai, AIR 40, 2025

The given case represents the dilemmas involved in the allocation of public funds in administration.

(a) Issues involved in the case

1. Allocation of public funds for competing requirements 2. Accemibility to basic services - education, health, water, roads. 3. Witchcraft and related crimes - against scientific temper (Fundamental duties) 4. Practices derogatory to women (Fundamental duties)

(b) Allocation of funds

Due to presence of competing requirements of development in the community the ethical dilemma arises in allocation of funds.

My justification for allocating a part of the development fund to witchcraft-related superstitions

1. The practice of witchcraft goes against the scientific and rational values 2. witchcraft-related crimes lead to breaching human dignity 3. without conducive social milieu and harmony other development efforts can't fructify. 4. The other developmental imperatives won't be compromised as adequate allocations shall be made. 5. will write to relevant authorities for special sanction of funds given the gravity of the crimes 6. Supplement govt funds by roping in NGO's and CSOs working in the related field.

(c) Measures for improving communication and transparency

Measures for improving horizontal as well as vertical communication in the department along with improvement of transparency

1. fostering healthy work culture 2. Gaining trust of subordinates through interpersonal relations. 3. Issuing a circular to assuring relevant authorities to report such incidents in a forthwith manner and warning of action if such incidents are intentionally withheld. 4. Developing in-house mechanisms for communication on a continuous basis 5. Being available through phone calls and e-mail.

Witchcraft is a menace in our modern societies. Public officials have moral as well as professional duty to deal with the menace in a comprehensive manner.