"The motive has nothing to do with the morality of the action." In light of the above statement, do you think motive is irrelevant in determining the morality of an action? Explain your position with relevant examples.
Diksha Rai, AIR 40, 2025
Motive refers to the intention of doing a particular act.
In Ethics it represents a classic dilemma of motive vs consequence.
However in my opinion motive is as relevant as morality of action.
An action cannot be morally tenable if it was done with wrong intention.
-> Helping others in order to gain social media followers by uploading reels -> Persuasion using manipulation. -> lying in order to save oneself (ethical egoism) -> Cheating in exam in order to make parents happy (good motive? but immoral action) -> Further an action can be ill-intended still can lead to moral action sometimes. eg- Saving a drowning person (intention to impress friends & gain popularity)
If the motive of an action is ill-intended, it instantly makes the action immoral (deontological school of thought)
For an action to be morally correct, the intention should also be good and moral.