Topper Copies

You are posted as the Additional District Magistrate (ADM) in a coastal district prone to flooding. During the monsoon season, rising river levels have led to early warnings from the disaster management unit. While reviewing preparedness files, you come across an internal report marked "confidential" generated by a recent IIT study. It identifies five low-lying zones that could face severe flash floods due to poor drainage and encroachment, including two residential clusters never marked as high-risk before. You ask the Disaster Management Officer (DMO) why this was not part of the public advisory. He says, "If we release this now, people will panic. Plus, there are real estate interests in those areas. Let's wait till there is a visible threat." You raise the issue with the District Collector, who replies, "We've alerted key departments. The public warning system is already stretched. We'll evacuate if needed." That evening, a local journalist sends you a Right to Information (RTI) query asking whether flood zone mapping has been updated. The DMO suggests you say "study still under review." You are conflicted. Sharing the report could save lives and push preventive action, but may trigger panic, disrupt the local economy, and place you at odds with senior officers. Delaying could lead to loss of life, for which you may later be blamed. 1. What are the competing ethical principles and administrative risks the ADM must consider in this case? 2. How should the ADM respond to the situation, balancing duty, protocol, and public interest? 3. Suggest three institutional practices that can improve transparency and responsiveness in disaster-prone districts.

Ananya Rana, AIR 60, 2025

Given case highlights the situation of indifference shown by higher authorities in a situation as severe as disaster management. This calls for administrative accountability and proactive action to save lives.

Competing ethical principles and administrative risks

Ethical principles 1. Duty to save lives of people 2. Efficient management of situation without causing panic 3. Upholding public trust in governance 4. Maintaining transparency in governance

Administrative risks

ADM's response balancing duty, protocol and public interest 1. Before releasing the report, must issue an address to the people about district's preparation to prevent collateral damage - will gain public trust 2. Release report himself and then reply to RTI by media accordingly - displays leadership in times of adversity 3. Simultaneously, issue warnings through DMO to the people of high risk zones about the protocol to be followed in event of disaster 4. Keep administrative machinery ready for evacuation. Further, call for extra resources from higher authorities and nearby districts 5. Apprise DC and higher authorities about preparation strategy 6. Regularly issue guidelines to people to maintain calm and act in responsible manner 7. Deployment of SDRF and NDRF by asking from higher authorities

Institutional practices to improve transparency and responsiveness in disaster prone districts 1. Proactive approach rather than reactive one - Regular mock drills among stakeholders to create disaster ready society and adequate infrastructure 2. During disaster - Adequate deployment of resources (food disbursal, water, medical aid) and forces (SDRF and NDRF) with frequent messaging to people - to ensure trust in governance 3. After disaster - Rehabilitation and reconstruction of facilities at faster pace. Ensuring adequate compensation to those in need

These 3 approaches based on Sendai Framework of Disaster Risk Reduction will help mitigate the after effects of disaster.