Topper Copies

You are the District Social Welfare Officer overseeing the rollout of a new AI-driven eligibility system for a state pension scheme. The goal is to eliminate manual errors and ensure the timely disbursal of funds. Within the first two months, you notice a sudden spike in beneficiary rejections, mostly from rural and tribal areas. Several elderly citizens arrive at your office with rejection letters. Some of them had been receiving pensions for years. They say their names are missing or "data not matching." You ask your team to review the backend. The system was developed by a private vendor and uses automated Aadhaar-matching and income estimation algorithms to verify claims. There is no option for appeal within the software interface, and rejections are auto-processed. Your technical advisor says, "It is working as designed. False positives are unavoidable, but overall, it is more efficient than manual review." However, field reports show rising distress. One rejected beneficiary allegedly died by suicide. You propose pausing the rollout and adding a manual review stage, but are told by the department secretary to avoid "slowing down reform." A media outlet has requested data on rejections, but the vendor insists on confidentiality. You are now caught between technological efficiency, vulnerable citizens, and institutional pressure to show success. 1. What are the ethical issues and administrative risks involved in this case? 2. Critically examine the options available to the officer. 3. What would be the best course of action to take? Justify. 4. Suggest safeguards that should be adopted when using AI-based systems in public welfare schemes.

Ananya Rana, AIR 60, 2025

The given case highlights the issue of biasness in AI algorithmic working that acts like a 'black box'. The situation demands right mix of compassionate and technical steps as solution.

Ethical issues and administrative risks involved

| Ethical risks | Administrative risks | |---|---| | Denial of rights to beneficiaries | Manual system reversal may increase errors | | Maintenance of public trust in governance | Risk of false information been spread by media | | A reversal to manual system will face reputational damage | Risk of law and order situation |

Options available with officer

Option 1: Continue with the AI system and address grievances on case-by-case basis.

| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Non-reversal to traditional system highlights government e-governance initiative | Situation may further degrade - suicides | | Redressal of cases filed | Government reputation at risk of damage |

Option 2: Completely stop the AI based system and start manual processing.

| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Right of beneficiaries upheld | Process may slow down | | No scrutiny by media | Cases of exclusion error may still persist | | Saving face of government | Corruption potential high |

Option 3: Pause the AI based system, call for vendor to correct the biases and in the meantime, disburse pension manually.

| Merit | Demerit | |---|---| | Micro scrutiny of each challenge | May slow the process | | Upholding dedication to public service | Biases of AI based system may not be removed completely | | Preventing reputational damage | |

Best course of action would be Option 3.

Along with this, a departmental inquiry must be launched to check authorization of vendor has followed all procedures or not.

This is best course because: 1. Gives vendor adequate opportunity to present his side - upholding principles of natural justice 2. Protection of vulnerable sections - elderly 3. Display of objectivity, rationality and leadership qualities by the officer

Safeguards needed while adopting AI-based systems for welfare schemes

Technology based 1. Ensure that the model AI created is free from bias and has adequate sampling 2. Implementing in phased manner to adequately study its impact 3. Adequate selection of vendor having prior experience of successful completion of such project

Grievance redressal based 1. Human touch should not be lost completely 2. Compassionate governance should be encouraged

AI is a double edged sword. Its implementation in public service delivery should be based on responsible and careful integration.