Advancement and diffusion of Knowledge is the only guardian of liberty.
Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025
"ADVANCEMENT AND DIFFUSION OF KNOWLEDGE IS THE ONLY GUARDIAN OF LIBERTY"
The year is 1965. In the campus of Banaras Hindu University (BHU) arrives a gentleman from Germany named Prof. Dietrich Conrad, a constitutional philosopher. He posed some novel yet concerning questions before the mild audience. 'Can the parliament amend the very constitution to an extent that it loses its basic features and becomes unrecognisable?' The questions were rhetoric and it sowed the seeds of novelty with respect to the limits of constitutional amendments under Article 368.
Cut to the southern-state of Kerala. A judge of the Kerala High court, Justice Nambiar, was too occupied with similar questions, looking at the winds flowing in the country at that timeperiod. Can liberty be usurped by the way of interpreting the constitution in an vague and arbitrary manner via Article 368 by the Parliament.
It took not so long. The year is 1975. Mrs Indira announces the proclaimation of Emergency and the opposition is silenced, the media gagged and the judiciary? A mute spectator as it aid the silencing of liberty with its bare hands in the ADM Jabalpur case or the Habeaus corpus case.
The advancement of and the diffusion of ideas of the two personalities viz Prof. Conrad and Justice Nambiar came true and ringed the bells to the Indians that a constant vigilance is the price of liberty.
Before dwelling into the crux and core of the essay, it is important to find the philosophical underpinning of growing liberty.
The foremost argument is that liberty is not a free-gift, it is the result of sacrifice of generations. John Stuart Mills writes in his book "On Liberty". This can be seen in the French Revolution, where the Bastille was stormed in pursuit of liberty, equality and fraternity.
Closer to home, during the constituent Assembly debates, H V Kamath too prophecised that liberty needs to be guarded continuously and it cannot be at any point taken for granted.
In sum, it can be put in the words of Alex de Tocqueville, 'Liberty is the fruit of a mature civilisation'.
The next question would be how to advance and diffuse Knowledge to guard the liberty?
The simplest of starting point can be to bring awareness among the school children. A sense of respect and reverence inculcated to the constitution and its ideals of liberty at a young age will help in claiming the civilisation that Tocqueville talked about.
Similarly, the media can act as the diffuser of Knowledge with programmes of constitution on the constituent assembly debates. The Rajya Sabha TV for example is an excellent example in this regard.
The Media has the responsibility to propagate ideas of importance to the mainstream, drawing attention to acts of usurpation of liberty.
Social movements can be a way of aggregation Knowledge and diffusing it. The example of JP Narayan's Sampoorna Kranti [?] the recent NRC-CAA protests are few examples.
Social media is emerging as a powerful tool to bring awareness about the ideals/ideologies/identities that threaten the pedestal of liberty.
However, advancement and diffusion of knowledge also may fall short in guarding the liberty. In this regard, other guardians too need to act in concert.
For example, an independent judiciary is a lifeblood of democracy and it acts the sentinel qui vive against any arbitrary impediments to liberty. For example, in the ROMESH THAPAR case (1950), SC held that Article 19, ensuring freedom speech and expression, is the palladium of liberty.
Similarly, in the Shreya Singhal case of 2014, SC diffused the knowledge about the grounds of limiting the liberty under Article 21.
However, the highest point came in the K.S. Puttaswamy judgement of 2017, when it upheld right to privacy as part of right to life, liberty and dignity.
Similarly, other guardians like constitutional bodies like UPSC, CAG, NCST/NCBC/NCSC/NCW/NHRC are some statutory bodies act as the bulwark of liberty enshrined in constitution (Dr. B.R Ambedkar).
Similarly, constitutional morality should triumph over public morality as highlighted in NAZ FOUNDATION & NAVTEJ SINGH JOHAR cases.
The cost of not guarding liberty? The dark age of Indian history post independence i.e the Emergency itself a powerful reminder of the repercussions of such ignorance.
Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt in their books How democracies die, highlight that they die when liberty undergoes a 'chilling effect' and when the tyranny of minority or the majority happens, it leads to democracies dying 'not with a bang but with a whimper'!
If liberty is not guaranteed, it leads to trampling the rights of minorities and give rise to two things: illiberal democracies (Forced majoritarianism) and democratic backsliding as seen in the world around.
Similarly, as B. R. Ambedkar held that justice is another name for liberty, equality and fraternity. The fact that he linked liberty and justice together, highlights the importance
What are the challenges to advancing and diffusing the knowledge, if it is known to quell the liberty?
The challenge to such a question lies within the system itself. For example, a committed judiciary, which is the vulgar form of its most ideal form "independent judiciary", is the biggest threat. The ADM Jabalpur highlighted that "where there is fear, there is no liberty (freedom)". And the decision in it seen as "judicial regret" in the history of supreme court.
Similarly, a committed and commercial media, that is devoid of media ethics of non-partisanship, neutrality and fair reporting is a threat and challenge to diffusing knowledge to the public.
For example, in the Arnab Goswami Case, the courts highlighted that media form the fourth pillar of democracy and it has the responsibility to weave the fabric of truth to secure the liberty of the citizenry.
However, the largest threat looms over such advancement of knowledge by a overreaching executive when the executive breaches the separation of powers doctrine of Montesquieu and usurps power beyond its sphere of influence, is the beginning of end of liberty.
The emergency is a stark reminder of thwarting the grand ideal of liberty via executive overreach, relegating the judiciary, media and movement to the periphery.
Thus, to sum up, we discussed how constant vigilance is the key to safeguard liberty and this is achieved via advancement and diffusion of knowledge. We also reminded ourselves of the importance of liberty and the sources of guarding such a liberty and challenge per se in acting so.
The cautionary questions posed by Prof. Conrad and Nambiar, which once were seen as only imaginary and far reaching, took no time i.e less than a decade to remind us that liberty is fragile and when left unguarded turns the tide and capsizes the boat of democracy quickly.
The diffusion of such knowledge were not just prophecies and it was Nani Palkhivala who was well versed with gentle reminders by both Conrad & Nambiyar, created the Doctrine of Basic Structure in the landmark "Kesavananda Bharati case".
It's a reminder, provocative yet powerful, that advancement and diffusion of knowledge is the only guarantian of liberty. 2025 marks 50 years to the dark period of Emergency and the message above should be the clarion calls to standing and safeguard the constitution. As Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore writes...
"Where the mind is without fear and head is held high, where the world is not broken into narrow fragments of walls, and words emerge from the depths of truth... Into that heaven, my father, let my country awake"