Topper Copies

Explain Arrow's impossibility theorem.

Ruhani, AIR 5, 2023

Arrow stated that there is no Social Welfare Function (SWF) that combines the preferences of all individuals of the society.

Assumptions - At least 2 individuals in society - At least 3 alternative social states.

Arrow's impossibility theorem It is impossible to construct a SWF that satisfies the following conditions of Arrow:

1. Ordering: A SWF should be an ordering i.e. it should be complete and transitive: - Complete: If A ≠ B, either A ≻ₛ B or B ≻ₛ A or A ~ₛ B. - Transitive: If A ≻ₛ B and B ≻ₛ C, then A ≻ₛ C 2. Unrestricted domain: All logically possible combinations of individual preference orderings must be admissible into the SWF. 3. Pareto principle: If all prefer x to y, then society must also prefer x to y. 4. Independence of irrelevant alternatives: The social preference ordering between x and y should depend only on individual ordering between x and y and not on other alternatives. 5. Non-dictatorship: There should be no individual i such that when he prefers x to y, then society also prefers x to y.

Thus, if these conditions are satisfied, it is impossible to construct a Social welfare function.