Topper Copies

Justice is the first virtue of social institutions, as truth is of systems of thought.

Mohit Gupta, AIR 58, 2025

On a sunny morning, in his official residence Justice H.R. Khanna was getting ready for his day at court, yet his heart was heavy and hands moved slowly as he put on his black coat. Sensing something was amiss, his wife asked, "Today is your big day, an important ruling has to be delivered, but you look distressed. why is that the case?"

Justice Khanna replied, "Today, I am going to pay the price of truth to uphold the justice. Today, I will deliver a judgement that is going to cost me my CJship". After saying this, he went to court and wrote a dissenting opinion in ADM Jabalpur Case.

In legal sense, it mattered little as Chilling effect of Emergency had forced other judges to agree to government's stance that Right to Habeas Corpus can be suspended. But Justice Khanna's dissent still symbolized that, "when truth resides in your system of thoughts, justice is embellished in social institutions".

Just as the above anecdote symbolized how justice becomes prime virtue of social institutions, this essay will explore the questions around justice, truth, their relevance and their interplay. So the first question which naturally strikes mind is, What is Justice In Aristotle?

- Aristotle while discussing four cardinal Virtues -> puts Justice at top and defines it as, "Justice is the quality of being fair." It is a practicing virtue where individuals & social institutions are fair in their Conduct based on unique situations & after accounting for all factors.

Justice is not theoretical, It is manifested as first virtue in different social institutions. In political sphere, It equates with rights of individuals and equal opportunity to exercise political power. Even our own Preamble guides us to build a Just society. It is basic political need in a democratic liberal setup, as Benjamin Franklin asserted after drawing "Bill of Rights", "Political Justice is part of basic human rights & bedrock of progressive society".

In social justice, justice relates to equity and positive intervention to build a just social order. It enables individuals to overcome disabilities & exercise their potential to the fullest. Social justice allows a boy selling newspapers to earn meagre income for family to become greatest rocket scientist & President of India, as APJ Abdul Kalam did.

However, social justice remains incomplete without economic justice as a life of dignity demands basic conditions of survival. In economic institutions, it is manifested in redistributive justice and unique provisions like Corporate Social Responsibility. Economic justice helps uplift complete potential of organizations & corporations. A testament to this is Land Reforms which when implemented in Bengal, raised state GDP by 17% within 5 years and percapita income by 8%, highlighting institutional reflect justice, prosperity of underemployed.

Similarly, ecological justice is necessary for sustainability and climate friendly development. Principles of Trusteeship and Common But Differentiated Responsibility reflect this essence of just distribution of not only resources but also duties among institutions, societies & nation.

We understood how justice permeates various social institutions, but a question arises is, Why is the first virtue in social institutions?

To investigate this, we need to understand what would happen in it's absence. In political institutions, justice is bulwark against tyranny of majority against minority. "When justice is absent, the institutions crumble, and anarchy prevails". A case in point is Racism where black had no political rights and even their bodies didn't belong to them. This unjust political setup led to most inhumane form of hierarchy history has witnessed.

Ever in social institutions injustice can create disabilities, prejudices & such deeply entrenched inequalities which are difficult to counter. When a Nirbhaya is raped in moving bus, or a medical student is raped at R G Kar College, it reflects gender injustice which results in worst crimes & disturbed social fabric.

In economic and ecological sphere, it results in extreme economic inequalities & rapid ecological degradation. While the former paints horrifying pictures of extreme poverty, impoverishment & ever hunger deaths, latter is reflected in climate disasters, climate refugees & overall uninhabitable earth.

Till now, we analyzed salience of justice as first virtue for social institutions, now let us understand why truth is paramount to system of thoughts?

So lets begin with understanding what truth is? Truth is ability of individual to be honest in thoughts, speech & action (Manasa, Vacha and Karma!).

Truth at individual level is reflected in not lying and at interpersonal level it is the quality of being non-deceptive.

To be truthful is not only to make a conscious effort, but one's thought subconsciously should also be truthful. It is ability to act out in way which is Consistent with our system of thoughts.

It is exemplified by an incident of Gandhiji. When a mother came to Gandhiji and asked him to scold her son for eating too much sugar. Gandhiji told her to come 15 days later and then he told the child that he should reduce his sugar intake.

But why did Gandhiji took those 15 days? He explained that earlier I myself was fond of sugar and by scolding the child was akin to lying. It is only when in my thoughts I was clear that sugar is bad for health, I could preach it to others.

Truth helps us avoid crisis of Conscience and allow integrity in our conduct.

But a natural question which arises is, "Why is truth first virtue of system of thoughts"?

This is because truth bestows us with the courage to counter lies. It helps us question the hegemony of what is natural. Truth enables rationality of our thoughts to be outwardly projected. This is what helped Rosa Parks to question discrimination against Blacks & which allows Ambedkar & Phule to question the caste system.

Truth enables trust building in Communities as when we recognize other person is truthful in action & thought can we cooperate with them. Although truth originates in our thoughts, yet is the foundation on which civilizations are built.

A simple case would be of one's own social circle, where one can connect with the other simply by placing our trust in them.

But presence of truth is like air, where presence is not discussed, but absence causes destruction & chaos. Absence of truth causes confusion of mind which can degrade social capital & threaten social order. All propaganda right from Nazism to Fascism and from [?] regime propounding caste to Manusmriti giving basis to patriarchy, all are based on lies to codified & amplified multiple times.

After discussing the salience of truth, it imperative to discuss how truth in system of thoughts leads to justice in social institutions?

Four truths of Buddha relating Justice to honesty of mind to Gandhiji asserting Nyaya & Satya as two pillars of social order, the relations between two is dynamic yet timeless.

At an individual level, truthfulness to one's values will compel him towards just actions. This is reflected in actions of Elon Musk who [?] his parents as he belived that innovations can spring up from any part of society and knowledge cannot be monopolised.

At organizational level, truthfulness protect consumer rights and enable just corporate policies. It leads to economic activities which promote social justice. AMUL established by Verghese Kurien exemplifies that truth when embedded in organizational structure leads to social upliftment of last in the line.

At social level, truth towards civilizational ethos helps build a harmonious and conflict-free social order. It helps provide political justice to citizens and just opportunities to marginalized.

At a national level, freely gives towards Constitutional values under justice not a value to be desired but a norm permeating socio-cultural fabric.

Truth originates with individual actions but like a domino effect - orient all social institutions towards justice.

Where ≠ Justice than a selfish self interest for truth, justice shines bright in society. For when he penned down his own thoughts in judgement he not only reflected that "truth is first virtue of system of thoughts" but also exemplified, "Justice is the first virtue of social institutions".