Topper Copies

Economic growth without investment in human development is unsustainable and unethical.

Kiran Kamate, AIR 53, 2025

"ECONOMIC GROWTH WITHOUT INVESTMENT IN HUMAN DEVELOPMENT IS UNSUSTAINABLE AND UNETHICAL"

India lives in two worlds. While one just crossed a GDP of 4.1 trillion USD, the other is thinking how to stretch food for the end of the month. While one builds statues, the other is still searching for toilet. While one is exploring exotic places like Bali, the other is still occupied within the four walls of household. Similarly, while one builds the highest bridge at Chenab, the other's bones are stretching the plains of Ganges.

This is what Sashi Tharoor called the 'Paradoxes of India' and standup comedian VIR DAS's e g come from two India's satirical comedy highlights.

The essay explores the divide between 'India and Bharat' and pinpoint at the bitter truth that economic growth without investment in human development is unsustainable and unethical.

Going by the first principles, economic growth measured by GDP is the overall increase in the goods and services produced with the domestic territory. According to IMF, India became the fourth largest economy in 2025, surpassing Japan and now only better USA, China and Germany. The overall GDP is now standing at 4.1 trillion dollars and India targets 5 trillion by 2027 and 7 trillion by 2030.

However, it is said the GDP measures everything in the economy except that which makes man's life worthwhile - implying that GDP is not a complete criteria to understand the growth of a country. In this context, development happens to be another important criteria.

It was the works of Mahbub-ul-Haq and Amartya Sen's works that led to what is now called as human development index (HDI) - consisting human development indicators like health, education, quality of life i.e standard of living.

Human development is the overall increase in the human capital ensured by investing the proceeds of the economic growth in health, education and skilling which inturn improves the income of the individual and ensures that he/she is liberated from the vicious cycle of "poverty and illiteracy" and gets in an virtuous cycle of "prosperity and inclusivity"

On the other hand, any economic growth without investment in such development parameters is a road to unsustainability and is unethical.

The philosophical foundations of economic growth having to inclusive with investments in human development comes from the thoughts of Gandhiji. He emphasised that commerce without morality as a sin and that is why he was averse to the ideas of modern growth paradigm led by industrialisation. This is captured well in the book "THE ECONOMIST GANDHI" by [?] Rao, where he posits that Gandhiji vouched for production by masses rather than mass production.

Similarly, Amartya Sen's capability approach is also a landmark philosophical underpinning of the issue. He focussed on emphasising investments in human capabilities than merely focussing on reservation & welfarism. The idea behind it was the famous chinese proverb "Give a man a fish, you feed him for a day, Teach him to fish and you feed him for life".

Thus, for Amartya Sen, improving the capabilities of people via investments in human development is a road to inclusive growth and sustainable development which was the "tryst with destiny" of 'leaving no one behind' and 'wiping every tear' that we had made on the eve of midnight of 15th August, 1947.

It is also pertinent to ask the question why then such a growth without taking into account the advise of A. Sen is an unsustainable growth (e.g) even worse unethical?

For starters, data shows 4.1 trillion USD GDP though laudable, it is only one & half of the story. If we take into account GDP per capita it is only under 3000 Dollars per person. But what makes it even worse is highlighted by the works of Oxfam International and works of Modern Marx, Thomas Pikketty's Capital in the 21st Century, which shows that top 1% of the population holds 22% of income and 40% of wealth. While the world succumbed to the miseries faced by a virus in 2019, the world also the number of billionaires - doubling in a span of 2-3 years.

Thus, such a economic growth that only uplifts the wealth of the top 1%, while the salaries of the bottom 30% [?] the employment becomes vulnerable, in an unethical zone.

In a similar vein, the growth of such model is unsustainable as it leads to [?] of the economy, as witnessed in India while the manufacturing sector gets outsourced out to the neighbouring chinese kingdom.

The growth of such an India which was claimed [?] because of jobless growth, now has turned even bitter with jobless growth.

It is unsustainable because, while an intermediary covers 65% of the market price paid by the consumers, the farmers after toiling for months under the straining debts and the vagaries of monsoon only gets a third of the final price. This according to Dr. Ashok Gulati, an agriculture economist, has led farmers to "debt and death".

Similarly, such a growth is unethical because it leaves the "largest untapped potential on earth" - women, behind in the India's growth story. As highlighted by Periodic labour force participation (PLFS) survey, the women labour force participation is just 41.7% - while that of China and USA are 52 and 64% respectively.

The lack of investment in women's higher education has lead to what McKinsey Report calls as 'leaky pipeline' - where women in STEM, start off well but they drop out midway. This is further hindered by unsafe institutions - the very place that were envisaged to empower her.

Taking a much wider view, it has led to "Neocolonialism" - here highlighted by Nobel prize winner Joseph Stiglitz's work 'Globalisation and its discontents'. The third world countries have been relegated to mere suppliers of raw materials and the increasing wealth of the Western world not commensurately distributed to them.

What then should be the way forward for a balanced economic growth - one that is sustainable and ethical.

Investment in health, education and skilling, with special focus on marginalised and women is of importance.

According to Dr. Karthik Muralidharan who in his recent book "Accelerating India's Growth" emphasises on improving the "capacity of the state" as the first major imperative. He highlights that India's programmes on social justice and welfarism are right, but India's practice of those programme is hindered by issues like pilferages, inclusion and exclusion errors, corruption, bureaucratic-apathy, lack of awareness, lack of data centric mapping and evidence-based policy making as major reasons.

Similarly, the economic growth itself can help in investing in human development. As argued by Arvind Panagariya (Chairman, 15th FC) and Jagdish Bhagwati, that the focus should be on economic growth acceleration. The fruits of such a growth will then be distributed to the investment in human development.

In summary, we understood how economic growth without investment in human development is unsustainable and reasons for it. The ideas of Rangaraja and Bhagwati, shed light on economic growth itself as a panacea for India's growth story.

The Indian government over the recent past has taken into account most of these suggestions and can be seen schemes like Aspirational Blocks and district programme, the recent PM-Dhan Dhaanya Krishi Vikas Yojana and extension of PM-JAY (Jan Aarogya Yojana) and the flagship National Education Policy (NEP) 2020.

Thus, Sarvodaya through Antyodaya is the model that India has adopted as highlighted by NITI Aayog's Bharatiya model of economic growth based on inclusive growth.

It is the recognition that there are human beings behind the statistics and the gulf between the goals and lived realities of those need to be bridged, inverting the Darwinian Dictum of 'survival of the fittest'. Ensuring survival of all.

"Sarve bhavantu sukhinah, Sarve santu niramayah"

[let all be happy and prosperous, let all be without diseases]