Topper Copies

Civilization begins with order, grows with liberty, and dies with chaos.

Diksha Rai, AIR 40, 2025

Civilisation Begins with order, grows with liberty and dies with chaos

Modern humans, evolved around 70,000 years ago, Human existence has thus been only a tiny part of existence of the universe. Still shorter has been the existence of civilisation which began around 5000 years ago. But since then humankind has made rapid advances in the terms of our ability to manipulate the physical world through sophisticate technologies. This ability to have a sense of control over our environment and well being is both result of and reason behind Civilisation.

In this essay we will explore the Origin & Civilisation, Its evolution through growth in liberty, and ultimately we will deal with the probable causes of its demise and how to avoid them.

The time before Civilisation : CHAOS

Before reaching the age of Civilisation, humans eked out a marginal existence, lacking the sense of superiority and strength over environments and other species, characteristic of present times.

People depended on gathering food and scavenging, with development of tools, man became hunters, but still lead a hand to mouth existence characterised by Nomadism. There was lack of certainty, and thus a constant struggle for survival.

As Thomas Hobbes, in Leviathan, expressed, human existence during that period was "nasty, brutish and short". Lack of political authority, laws and general rules and regulations aided in the selfish instincts of humans resulting in a society wherein each band was suspicious of the other. This lack of trust and social cooperation lead to chaos and general lack of order.

Age of Civilisation : Characterised by order

As humans began domesticating plants and animals, theirs population grew. The provision of surplus food enabled people to live in permanent settlement. This was the beginning of the arrival of order in human societies.

Man became capable of indulging in other occupations as food was now not the only thing to be worried for as settled agriculture lead to enough foodgrain production with fewer hands. Thus began the specialisation of occupations such as metallurgy, pottery, trade, jewellery making, etc. The simultaneous development of written language gave a major push towards the development of civilisation.

These enabling circumstances, led to the development of state, political institutions, law and thus order in social life. People were bound in so called "Social" contract. Social relations were characterised by respect to each other's rights and voluntary commitment to adhere general rules and regulations.

Celebrated author, Yuval Noah Harari in his book "Sapiens", argues that people's ability to cooperate with each other on a large scale is the most significant reason behind relative success of humankind as a species'. Civilisation is characterised by such cooperation.

The famous town planning of Indus Valley Civilisation signifies the importance of order which came along with civilisation. As people began cooperating at a large scale, the progress in society witnessed an exponential pace. Within 5000 years of the beginning of civilisation we have been able to set foot on Moon as have we taught machines how "to think".

Civilisation Grows with liberty

As the human Civilisation progressed humans became increasingly self capable in fulfilling their basic needs. Sophisticated technologies of agricultural production, storage, trade and division of labour pushed humans towards realising higher order needs.

People began to wonder about philosophical questions such as what's meaning of existence? Is there a higher power above us? What happens when we die? This curiosity to unravel the mystery of human existence led to the development of Religion and Philosophy. The Vedic texts and Upanishads, written thousands of years ago grapples with these questions. However free flow of ideas and philosophy is conditioned on the presence of liberty. Socrates, the venerated Greek Philosopher had to die due to his "eccentric ideas". Similarly Copernicus, Galileo and numerous other such "eccentrics" faced persecution for expounding ideas and scientific facts which were against the predominant & prevalent wisdom of the Time. This led to stagnation of Civilisation in the medieval period, called "Dark Ages" in Europe. Civilisational progress was gasping for the breath of liberty!

The fresh air of liberty swept through Europe and subsequently most of the world during Renaissance and scientific revolution.

From the invention of spinning Jenny and Powerloom to spaceships and Char GPT, humans were able to achieve such dramatic technological progress due to Freedom - freedom to express, innovate and pursue one's ideas and convictions.

Liberty also led to political progress. From the Glorious revolution of 1688, the ideas of liberty and limited government gained pace. American Revolution led to establishment of the first democracy in the world based on the foundation of rights of 'men'.

Again, French Revolution, remarkably spread the ideals of Liberty, Equality and Fraternity which became rallying call later on for many colonies struggling for independence.

Philosophers like Rousseau, John Locke and Voltaire had a major role to play in the political revolutions across continents. They argued for the quintessential respect to rights and liberties of men.

Liberty Preamble of India, not disconnected from the context, espouses the liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith and worship.

Similarly the liberty to movement both within & outside country eventually led to Globalisation and the world becoming a Global village. The progress of Civilisation gained from ensuring free flow of ideas and people.

Multiculturalism and multiethnicity has been only possible because of people's liberty to choose and conserve their identities and affiliations.

However, Despite all these advantages of liberty, it is not an absolute right.

Absolute liberty: Recipe for chaos

Liberty is generally explained to be state of absence of external constraint. But one should not get entangled in such simplistic view of liberty.

The constitution of India also mentions limitations to liberty in the form of exceptions to freedom of speech and expression.

John Locke, in "On Liberty" had explained the axiomatic principle on liberty - The Harm principle. One's liberty is limited by the prospect of causing harm to others. This liberty as a concept demands mutual respect of others rights. Thus both absence of liberty and pursuit of absolute liberty is harmfull to the progress of civilisation as it leads to chaos.

Chaos unchecked leads to demise of Civilisation

In the absence of proper checks, regulations and cooperation among people, suspicion and derision is born.

A civilisation, while thrives because of order and stability, gets threatened due to lack of it. Chaos ensues when people start practising liberty in [?] absence of social context. The purported liberty to practise one's own religion without respecting right of others to do the same led to mutual wars of attrition during crusades.

One of the most inhuman episodes which threatened humanity and thus civilisation was the period of world war II when Nazis in Germany denied the most basic liberty - right to live to a whole section of the population. 6 Million jews were exterminated in concentration camps through heart wrenching and bone chilling methods.

The word realised the need to establish order post two world war 2 and took various steps to check chaos. United Nations was institutionalised and Universal Declaration of Human Rights delineated the baselines below which no society is supposed to fall.

Contemporary threats and How to Deal with them

The contemporary challenges of terrorism, religious extremism, human trafficking, Instability and war are all increasing the chaos, collectively humanity faces.

While a bit of chaos is needed for progress, there needs to be concerted efforts to conserve & protect people's liberty and check chaos.

Global institutions like UN, WHO, FAO as well as countries themselves need to act responsibly to resolve conflict & foster harmony.

Indian philosophies of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam (Oneness of humanity and nationalistic boundaries) and Sarva Dharma Sambhava are guiding lights for world peace and civilisational progress.

"We need to learn to live together or we will perish together" - Carl Sagan.