How does mediation differ from arbitration? In light of the recent enactment of the Mediation Act, of 2023, assess its potential to address the backlog of litigations in Indian courts and foster a culture of voluntary mediation, especially among private players and public-sector undertakings.
Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025
Mediation and Arbitration are the forms of Alternate Dispute Resolution aimed to promote efficiency in judiciary.
| Mediation | Arbitration | |---|---| | Process whereby a mediator may facilitate dispute resolution between two parties. | Here an arbitrator gives judgement in a dispute between two parties. | | Governed by Mediation Act, 2023. | Governed by Arbitration and Conciliation Act. | | Decision needs to be enforced by court. | Judgement is binding. | | Mediation Council of India will provide for mediators. | Arbitrators identified as per the Act. |
Potential to address backlogs
1. It will help in resolving pendency of cases. Example: Around 5 crore cases are pending overall (National Judicial Datagrid) 2. It will help in peaceful dispute since it does not follow complex procedural laws and follows principle of natural justice. 3. Useful tool as it has very high success rate (≈ 65-70% success rate) 4. It will help to maintain confidentiality of the information - much desired in family disputes. 5. Reduce burden as can be opted pre-litigation.
However, challenges remain:
1. May add further burden in case dispute not resolved. 2. Confidentiality will create issue in further litigation. 3. Not helpful in case of power asymmetry as the decision seems to be biased in case of powerful party. 4. Requires court intervention for enforcement. 5. No provision if party does not follow the judgement.
Thus Mediation Act has the potential to address litigation - Reforms need to be made for further efficiency.