What are the powers and immunities of the Governor in relation to bills passed by the state legislature? Are these powers unlimited in nature? Discuss in light of relevant judgements.
Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025
Article 153 states that there shall be a Governor who shall be the head of State Executive.
Power and immunities of Governor
1. Article 200: Governor has power either 1. To give assent 2. To withhold assent 3. To send the bill for re-consideration provided it is not a money bill 4. Send the bill for reservation for President. 2. Governor has to reserve the bill for President in case the bill violates the powers of High Court. 3. President's sanction required for bills dealing with inter-state trade and commerce. 4. Article 361: Grants immunities to the Governor - decision cannot be questioned.
No, these powers are not unlimited as highlighted by SC judgements
1. Shamsher Singh Case: Governor is bound by the advice of Council of Ministers 2. Punjab Case (2023): Governor cannot sit on bill indefinitely. Also, governor if withheld assent should sent the bill back and cannot withhold again. 3. Tamil Nadu Case (2023): Cannot reserve for the President if legislature returns after withholding.
Thus Supreme Court through various judgements helps to balance state autonomy/federalism.