"The right to internet access is integral to the realization and exercise of other fundamental rights in India." In this context examine how the recognition of internet access as a fundamental right in India reconciles with the state's authority to impose restrictions.
Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025
Right to internet has been a debated issue in recent times on account of frequent internet shutdowns (#6 in 2023) the largest in the world.
Reconciling with state's authority
1. Anuradha Bhasin Case: Right to internet is subject to reasonable restrictions mentioned in Article 19(2) - sovereignty, integrity etc - Also, State must ensure that internet shutdown is temporary. 2. Federal Association vs State of J&K Case: Supreme Court mentioned that internet shutdown must not harm business, health in the name of national interest. 3. Parliamentary Committee - Doctrine of proportionality to be used - OTT services must be regulated not for complete ban. 4. State has to protect individual privacy. 5. Internet shutdown for non-state actors, to protect state.
Thus right to internet is a sensitive right which must be used for betterment.