How do the citizenship laws and policies of India and the United States differ within their constitutional frameworks? Comment on the ongoing debate on citizenship laws and policies in India and the US.
Nancy Singh, AIR 34, 2025
India is the largest democracy while USA is the oldest democracy.
Citizenship laws and policies differ of India and USA.
| India | USA | |---|---| | Grants single citizenship. | Grants dual citizenship - Federal and that of state. | | Part II (Article 5-11), Citizenship Act, 1955 deals with Citizenship. | Amendment XIV looks into provisions of citizenship. | | Jus soli and jus sanguine - grounds of citizenship. | Only on the basis of jus soli. | | Citizenship by naturalisation allows one to contest for President. | Citizenship by naturalisation does not allow one to contest for President. |
Ongoing debates
1. India: CAA 2019 - Aims to grant citizenship to minorities from Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Pakistan - National Register for Citizens to be conducted - Refugee and illegal migration 2. USA: Birth tourism where jus soli principle is misused - Citizenship of USA but neither parent is citizens creates issues - Issues related to H1B visa.
Ongoing debates need to be resolved to promote social cohesion and harmony.