Rakesh is a responsible district-level officer, who enjoys the trust of his higher officials. Knowing his honesty, the government entrusted him with the responsibility of identifying the beneficiaries under a healthcare scheme meant for senior citizens. The criteria to be a beneficiary are the following: (a) 60-years of age or above. (b) Belonging to a reserved community. (c) Family income of less than 1 Lakh rupees per annum. (d) Post-treatment prognosis is likely to be high to make a positive difference to the quality of life of the beneficiary. One day, an old couple visited Rakesh's office with their application. They have been the residents of a village in his district since their birth. The old man is diagnosed with a rare condition that causes obstruction in the large intestine. As a consequence, he has severe abdominal pain frequently that prevents him from doing any physical labour. The couple has no children to support them. The expert surgeon whom they contacted is willing to do the surgery without charging any fee. However, the couple will have to bear the cost of incidental charges, such as medicines, hospitalization, etc., to the tune of rupees one lakh. The couple fulfils all the criteria except criterion 'b'. However, any financial aid would certainly make a significant difference in their quality of life. How should Rakesh respond to the situation?
Deeksha Chourasiya, AIR 44, 2025
The above case study is a perfect ethical dilemma between moral subjectivity and rule of law (objectivity). While the NITI (law) does not allow alterations, NYAY (justice approach) allows for compassionate governance.
Rakesh's ideal course of Action 1. Rakesh must consult his higher officials to resolve the dilemma. 2. If he is not able to include the couple in the existing scheme, then he must look for other income based schemes like PM - Ayushman Bharat etc. 3. The main role is NGOs and civil society for aid and can arrange a crowd funding 4. Further, state officials can aid the couple in subsidised public hospitals 5. If mother wants out, father can help the couple in his personal capacity by giving beyond the value of duty.
Reasons for Actions 1. The idea of "welfare state" in India envisages Antyodaya and Sarvodaya i.e. inclusive development of all. 2. Compassionate governance is the cornerstone of Ethical governance 3. Human right based Justice approach (Veil of "ignorance") prefers moral subjectivity over Objectivity, 4. Cannot go against the rule of law / scheme as it can set wrong precedent (Broken window syndrome) 5. Dedication to duty - compels Rakesh to go beyond the call of fiduciary duty towards constitutional duty.
Thus, Rakesh must try all options available to provide the couple financial aid while being within rule of law.
As Mahatma Gandhi said, "You can find yourself by losing yourself in the service of others"