Topper Copies

"While competence without compassion can be brutal and inhuman; similarly, compassion without competence can be meaningless for persons seeking help." Explain the above with the help of a suitable illustration in the context of public services.

Deeksha Chourasiya, AIR 44, 2025

"Intelligence without character gives birth to a clever devil."

Competence and compassion are 2 values that cannot be interchanged and needs to co-exist.

Competence without compassion 1. Misuse of Power - great leaders like Indira Gandhi (1975 Emergency) - misused power. 2. Unethical corporate governance - greenwashing by Volkswagen against planet's net-zero 3. Global injustice - US & high competence yet vaccine protectionism during COVID showed unethical leadership 4. Against the Basic human rights and constitutionalism 5. AQ Khan (Pakistan scientist) sold unchecked codes

Compassion without competence 1. Meaningless as unimpowered to help/aid. Eg> mob lynching against child abductors against rule of law 2. Does not result in sustainable actions to solve problems. Eg> Judicial over-reach for Ban against alcohol. 3. Break down of Objectivity Eg> civil servant unethically adding new names in scheme beneficiary

Thus, Buddha's middle path of balancing both is necessary to attain effective public service Delivery. Even (Kautilya) envisaged a "righteous king with strong value of justice & competence for good governance"