Topper Copies

Ethical guidance in public administration stems from various sources, laws, rules, regulations, and personal conscience. These sources may not always align. In such cases, what ethical approach should a public servant adopt to resolve the conflict? Illustrate with examples.

Ananya Rana, AIR 60, 2025

Ethical determinants comprise various sources like constitution, laws, spiritual texts and they may not always be in consonance. This situation will call for 'constitutionally guided conscience' approach.

Non-alignment of determinants of ethics 1. Law may be against societal beliefs - eg society still discriminates against LGBTQIA+ community 2. Situations involving loved ones - eg A relative involved in accident 3. Situations of scarcity - eg Black marketing during COVID

Ethical approach required during such times 1. Strong Emotional intelligence which will guide towards correct path - eg not using force against peaceful protestors on orders of seniors 2. Constitution as lighthouse! and upkeeping of constitutional morality - eg not separating an inter-religious couple if truly have wilfully married 3. Past precedents may guide - eg Actions of seniors 4. Importance of upholding of public trust - eg Not evicting at mid of night

Such situations demand careful consideration of multiple factors and choosing a madhyam marga!