Topper Copies

You are posted as the Joint Secretary in the Department of Information Technology of a state. The government recently implemented several citizen-centric digital services, collecting large volumes of personal data from residents. The Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023, requires that such data be processed only with explicit and informed consent, and mandates that processing must cease immediately upon withdrawal of consent. During an internal audit, you discover that the department continues to process and analyze personal data of several citizens even after they have formally withdrawn their consent. This data is being used for policy analytics and service improvement, purposes not explicitly disclosed at the time of data collection. When you bring this to the attention of your department head, you are informed that halting the processing will disrupt ongoing digital initiatives and may affect state-level performance metrics. Moreover, you find that the consent withdrawal process is cumbersome, and many citizens are unaware of their rights under the DPDP Act. You also learn that a prominent social activist is planning to file a complaint with the Data Protection Board against involuntary use of personal data, which could attract public scrutiny and legal action against the department. (a) Identify and discuss the ethical issues involved in this case. (b) What are the potential consequences for the department if the issue is not addressed transparently? (c) How would you balance the need for efficient public service delivery with the obligation to protect citizens' data rights? (Answer in 250 words)

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

The case highlights violation of digital privacy [Art 21] (Puttaswamy case) due to violation of Supreme Court judgement of Doctrine of proportionality.

a) Ethical issues involved

1. Means VS end: while data privacy violated for service improvement, procedural propriety disregarded 2. Slippery slope: lays ground for future dubious use → thus grave consequences 3. Unaware citizens about their rights. Thus enhanced role of civil servant → fiduciary duty 4. Betrayal of trust amounts to corruption 5. Violates [Art 14]: equality, as no 'intelligible differentia' or 'rational nexus' with the goals 6. Kant's idea of categorical imperative → against duty ethics → do disclosure or data records 7. Lack of citizen centric governance: no informed consent taken 8. Violates rules: executive overreach → violation of accountability [legislative accountability issue] 9. Digital enroads → 'panopticon' and surveillance state (eg China)

b) Consequences if not addressed

It may appear small but in long term has cascading effect. "Compromise between good and better, not between good and evil." Such compromise is Faustian bargain leading to:

1. Supreme Court litigation → may lead to penalty [Accountability] 2. Legislative oversight by PAC after audit → department might face punitive measures 3. Loss of trust if media trial 4. Violation of trusteeship relationship

Personal issue for civil servant: compromise integrity, honesty, loss of character.

5. Procedural propriety vs bureaucratic high handle: gap is Good Governance, democratic governance may transition towards dictatorship/autocracy 6. If litigation, long term data based governance under scrutiny, impacts efficiency, effectiveness 7. Snowball effect: citizen might not be willing to share data, reduced cooperation in long run 8. Personal consequence for Joint Secretary: dereliction of duty, crisis of conscience vs ethical dilemma

c) Balance efficient service delivery with obligation to protect rights

1. If rules are made by executive (delegated legislation), they must be for a reason. Thus sidestepping is no solution 2. Process only data required: proportionality doctrine 3. Develop systems which automatically delete data after work done 4. Citizen Charter and awareness about rights 5. Due disclosure and informed consent of citizen, aid digital literacy and provide grievance redressal 6. Innovation: other methods to do service improvement (eg Meta Data, ERP Software, SAP processes) 7. Doctrine of unintended consequences: try to mitigate collateral damage 8. Proactive disclosure: RTI Sec 4

"To ignore convenient reality, only compounds it, to sidestep evil only multiplies it and ignoring the bully only invites the butcher." Integrity is important to avoid mistake turning into failure, as what appears small ends up becoming a constitutional crisis. Thus good means for ends [Minerva Mills Case].