Goodness is the result of internal imperatives to do what is right, not sanctions from moral rules or rewards from expected consequences. Do you agree? Discuss.
Deeksha Chourasiya, AIR 44, 2025
motivation to follow morality or righteousness can come from multiple sources.
Kohlberg has given 3 broad levels of moral development:
1. Pre conventional : obedience and punishment driven by self interest Eg) Not Cross signal due to fear of fines. 2. Conventional morality : social conformity driven by need for approval Eg) Filing a PIL for labourers to get moral recognition 3. Post conventional morality : behaviour driven by internal moral necessity Eg) Nelson mandela's decision of granting forgiveness to perpetrators of Apartheid.
Thus, at different stages, different tools are used to mould morality.
- Rewards and expected consequences like 'leadership award' and hope for a promotion can motivate self interest actions ie/ethical egoism) - But this is narrow, hedonistic and not with rightful intent. - Goodness in its pure sense comes from non-reciprocal deed of Public interest. - It is choosing between what right you have to do actions and what is the right action
Ex => S.C. Bose left civil services post for Nation service.
Such selfless acts of goods (post conventional morality) is the highest ideal yet other models for moral persuasion like rewards/punishment also play important role in reaching upto that level.