What are the challenges of Green Revolution? Do you think they could have been avoided?
Ruhani, AIR 5, 2023
Green revolution began in 1966 and increased the production of wheat and rice in the country. However, it created a few challenges:
1) It remained limited to [rice and wheat]: - Rice and wheat were the mainstays of the revolution. Thus, other crops like pulses and oilseeds and millets remained neglected.
2) [IMPACT ON EMPLOYMENT]:- According to Ms. Sheila Bhalla, the employment elasticity of output declined from 0.7 in 1966 to 0.5 in 1980. -> Thus, green revolution reduced labour absorption in agriculture. -> As per C.H. Hanumantha Rao, use of labour-saving technologies by large farmers like tractors, threshers and harvesters displaced 20% of labor days per acre. -> As per J. Mohan Rao, the Green Revolution led to shifting of jobs away from agriculture into 'rural industries'.
3) [REGIONAL INEQUALITIES]:- The green revolution remained confined to Punjab and Haryana where agricultural rate of growth climbed to 5% and 3% respectively.
[a rough outline map of India marking Punjab (5%) and Haryana (3%)]
-> This is because these two states had a good tubewell irrigation infrastructure which is crucial for the success of HYV technology. -> Green Revolution spread to the North East and Southern states only after 1980s once they developed their tubewell irrigation infrastructure.
4) [INTERPERSONAL INEQUALITIES] increased as only large farmers could afford to buy inputs like HYV seeds, fertilizers and machinery. Small farmers could not get credit easily and hence, they failed to transition to HYV technology and benefit from the green revolution.
These challenges could have been avoided under the following conditions: - if the revolution increased production and yields of all crops (and not just rice and wheat) - if Small farmers and tenants could get timely credit - had land reforms been successful, tenants would not be facing eviction problems - if Tubewell irrigation infrastructure was strengthened all over India.
Despite these challenges and shortcomings, Green revolution has played a seminal role in making India self-sufficient in food grains.