With regard to the morality of actions, one view is that means is of paramount importance and the other view is that the ends justify the means. Which view do you think is more appropriate? Justify your answer.
Deeksha Chourasiya, AIR 44, 2025
Teleological school of thought upholds consequentialism (ends important) whereas deontological school supports means over ends. Thus the debate over morality is contentious.
Teleological approach Advantages: 1. Allows moral relativism according to the need Eg Yudhisthira telling white lie that Ashwathama is dead 2. upholds ethical utilitarianism i.e. good for all approach Eg Quick clinical trials during COVID to save lives. 3. Aids in flexible actions and ensure justice at end Eg Robin hood steals for good
Fallouts of ends over means 1. leads to moral ambiguity in life 2. Against rule of law (principles) 3. leads to unjust means to get just ends (Ex:- Mob lynching)
Deontological approach Advantages: 1. Kantian duty based ethics ie Nishkama Karma 2. supports universal categorical values like honesty. 3. Right means for rightful ends ensures long term justice Ex) Mahatma Gandhi's non violence. 4. support human centric approach to virtue ethics.
Thus means are of utmost paramount importance and cannot be compromised for the end as seen in the violent Israel - Hamas war. So, intent of action of a civil servant must be in line with constitutional duty.