Case Study 4: A smart city project is underway, and you have been appointed Head of Procurement. Before this assignment, you held a similar role in a major public sector undertaking (PSU), where you earned a reputation for your tender drafting and vendor management skills. Given the smart city project's scale and significant procurement requirements, you seemed the perfect fit to lead the procurement section. A month ago, your section invited tenders for building supplies. Among the applicants was Mr. Sharma, a supplier you knew from your previous role at the PSU. Mr. Sharma lived in your neighbourhood, and your spouses were friends. Despite this personal connection, you have always maintained strict professional boundaries. Upon scrutinising all the tenders, your section found Mr. Sharma's terms the most competitive, so the tender was awarded to him. However, once the decision was made public, another vendor, Mr Patel, accused you of colluding with Mr Sharma due to your previous relationship. Mr. Patel filed a formal complaint with the Department Seniors, providing evidence of your prior association with Mr. Sharma. As a result, an enquiry was initiated, and you were placed on compulsory leave pending its outcome. This situation left you questioning where you might have gone wrong despite your efforts to maintain professionalism. 1. Do you think the above case involves a conflict of interest or there are more issues? Explain 2. Keeping the above case in perspective, discuss the relevance of impartiality and non-partisanship as professional value. 3. In hindsight, how do you think you could have avoided the above unpleasant situation.
Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025
The above case study reflects instances where personal and professional interest collide, leading to conflicts.
Issues of conflict and other issues in the case
While prima facie, for outsiders, it may reflect a conflict of interest and an instance of collusive competition, I always maintained professional standards: - Bid was the most competitive - Transparent decision making
Other issues: 1. False charges initiated by competitors, leading to legal ramifications, loss of reputation 2. Departmental enquiry without giving an opportunity to be heard (shows lack of communication and procedural flaws in bureaucracy)
Relevance of impartiality and non-partisanship in the profession
1. Impartiality + non-partisanship → increased trust in decision making → good and ethical governance 2. As civil services and professionalism require autonomy and dealing with multiple stakeholders, impartiality is important for 'transparency' eg. T.N. Seshan was impartial and non-partisan and even launched a complaint against ruling party ministers who violated electoral laws 3. Saves the individual from unnecessary charges of collective corruption and helps keep a 'clean image' 4. Enhances respect in the service and can deal with the case based on its merit 5. 2nd ARC calls them an essence of good work culture as it leads to non-interference and proper decisions
How I could have avoided the situation
1. Made the process more transparent by publicly displaying the facts of both the tenders 2. Could have invited all the vendors and had a discussion over objections ↳ that could have pointed out if Mr. Sharma's tender was competitive or not, and could have created better competition 3. Could have intimated the senior about the decision and kept them in the loop over the decision 4. Could also have recused myself, as I had personal relations with Mr. Sharma, and if it was competitive, it would ultimately be selected
Thus, I could have taken the above precautions to ensure a more transparent process and saved myself from the conflict of interest.