In public administration, ethical decision-making is shaped by multiple frameworks. How does a deontological or duty-based ethical approach differ from consequentialist theories such as utilitarianism in administrative practice? Illustrate your answer with an example of a moral dilemma in governance.
Ananya Rana, AIR 60, 2025
Deontological approach keeps the means to achieve an end at its heart whereas utilitarianism calls for achieving "greater good for greater numbers".
Difference between deontological approach and utilitarianism
| Deontological approach | Utilitarianism | |---|---| | Focuses on duties to be performed with all morality | Focuses on ends of the actions performed | | Proposed by Emmanuel Kant, Mahatma Gandhi | Proposed by Jeremy Bentham | | There can be no wrong way to do the right thing | 'Ends' have to be given more significance than 'means' | | Emphasises on principle of 'categorical imperative' | Promotes pleasure for greater number of people | | Example: would want ethical means always | Example: would support Robinhood like activities |
Moral dilemma in governance: When a dam has to be built, few tribals would have to be displaced.
Thus, their application is context specific and demands rational use of moral and ethical principles.