Administrative ethics often involve tension between legality and morality. As a public administrator, how would you handle a situation where legal compliance contradicts moral responsibility? Illustrate with an example.
Ananya Rana, AIR 60, 2025
Legality refers to the approach of administration based on legal framework - Constitution, statutes, by-laws etc. Morality is the principles on which conduct of a person is measured eg honesty, punctuality etc.
Tension between legality and morality in administration
Balancing of situation when legal compliance contradicts moral responsibility
Situation: When an old lady who has lost all documents in a recent flood approaches PDS shop to have grains, but does not possess eligible documents to avail services.
- Legal compliance demands - She should be refused grains - Moral responsibility demands - Hungry person should not be denied food
Course of balancing: Old lady should be provided with sufficient grains to ensure her survival. In the meantime, new documents should be made with administrative urgency.
The purpose of legal compliance is not exclusive of morality. Rather both aim to reinforce each other. Hence, a harmonious balance between both is the need of the administration.