Topper Copies

"I am a Moslem; I am a Hindu; I am a Christian; I am a Jew." Mahatma Gandhi. What did Mahatma Gandhi mean by the above statement? Some philosophers have argued that religion is harmful to the moral life, whereas others have claimed that it is necessary to it. Explain your position on the relationship between religion and morality.

Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025

Morality represents adherence to moral principles that have internal and universal application.

Religion represents 'collective tradition' based on faith, worship and community.

Gandhiji's Statement 1. Gandhiji tried to explain his secular nature and show how every religion is essentially the same 2. His essence was to ensure 'equality', mutual respect and 'Sarva dharma Sambhav'

Religion as harmful 1. Based on irrational ideas and strengthens superstition => animal sacrifices 2. Leads to issue of communal violence and fundamentalism as individual identity superseded by religion => terror attacks by ISIS, Al Qaeda 3. Rationality and reform undermined so morality based on 'collectivity' => Sabarimala issue

Religion as necessary for moral life 1. Organizing force -> leads to ideal and ethical behaviour 2. Founded on moral and ethical principle => dignity of humans, equality, love

[a diagram: "Religion" drawn as a set resting on "morality" as its base]

3. Motivating force for good behaviour and also social sanction => religious panchayat

Position: Religion is often founded on morality and thus both complement.

We must ensure reform of dogmatic practices by rationality and morality.

Indian government's UCC (Article 44), DPSP, aims to balance religion and morality, evident in its secular model.