"It is wrong to assume that ethical decisions are, can or should be purely rational and principled. Human feelings are an inseparable part of our ethical life." In what way do feelings impact our ethical decisions? Illustrate with examples.
Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025
Human mind is both rational as well as has 'passion' i.e. feelings which guide our ethical decision making.
[a Venn diagram of two overlapping circles, "Reason/Rationality" and "Passion/feeling", the shaded overlap pointing to "Ethical Decision" — fig 1, Cognitive Component of human]
Ethical decisions as rational and principled:
1. Based on established standards and thus 'collective reasoning' => [?], equality in society 2. Universal principle => Kant's categorical imperative 3. Based on determinant like laws, science which are rational
However, if man is guided by reason, he also has feelings that affect his decisions:
1. Listening to our 'conscience' is unethical but necessary ▷ paying money to kidnapper 2. Compassion leads us to break standards of ethics ▷ mercy to criminals 3. Makes our decision more emotive ▷ feelings of anger would lead to civil disobedience against unjust law
Thus, the right balance of rational principles and feelings i.e. 'Golden mean' would produce good ethical decision and serve the ultimate aim of 'Summum bonnum'.