Topper Copies

"Truth, like a torch, the more it is shook, it shines."

Aditya Srivastava, AIR 1, 2023

"Truth like a torch, the more it is shook, the more it shines"

If we take a time machine and travel to the year 1610, we will find an old man, watching the sky with his telescope and making some observations with his tired eyes and nimble fingers. If the timing is right, we can see him shaking the foundation of the widely accepted truth of the Ptolemaic system with his newly discovered theory of heliocentricity. This man was none other than well known scientist Galileo who, with his scientific temper had refused to blindly accept the truth without viewing it through his lens of rationality.

It is only once in a blue moon when we see such breakthrough discoveries but then, that is the nature of truth. Until it is shook vibrantly, it tends to remain in its absolutist state. Yet we see that people now and again continue to perform the herculean task of establishing a new normal by challenging the normalized truth through their discoveries.

It becomes necessary to question the perceived truth because it is only through questioning that new knowledge can be gained. The Socratic dialectic method tells us how every thesis should be countered by an antithesis to critically analyze the acceptability of the thesis. In such an attempt by Einstein, he came across the flaws of the Newtonian physics and added the new knowledge of relativity which is helping us even today to get a deeper understanding of the universe.

Apart from new knowledge, it helps us to synthesize opposing views and develop tolerance to the rights and dignity of the parties with those opposing views. A similar voyage by the hon'ble Supreme Court in the Navtej Johar Case helped to recognize the right to liberty and dignity of the LGBT community. Apart from individual rights, it also helped to enrich and strengthen our society by promoting the inclusivity of diverse ideas and assertions.

The pre-Navtej Johar era presents us a picture of static society which was living in its own figment of imagination about the bigoted interpretation of liberty. A very similar case of bigotry is presented by the OnlyFans revolution of USA whereby women just accepted the projected truth without questioning and fell prey to the sexual fantasies of the same delirious men from whom they wanted liberty!

Many times such projected realities are presented to us for some selfish propaganda. In such cases, separating the wheat from the chaff becomes imperative to uphold not just our individuality but also the security of our nation. The terrorist propaganda as shown in the movie Kerala Stories and the glorification of martyrdom are such hideous and cruel attempts. They need the full human capacity to shake the projected truth with vigour as well as perseverance to unearth the slow poison being given via brainwashing.

Another categorical imperative here is to re-think our strategies which might be failing and think about course correction. One of the researches comparing human development index with women participation in science and engineering shows just how flawed the understanding of free choice leading to equality of outcomes can be! The negatively sloped graph shows how with increasing human development and corresponding improvement in equality of opportunity, the women's share in STEM fields progressively goes down - with only 25% in Finland and a whooping 48% in Algeria!

However this leads to the question of how long we should create ripples in the known truth? One of the considerations here comes from the picture of a wailing Jewish woman running away from German tyrant kids. The mass psychosis created by Hitler's travesty of ideas had penetrated deep even to hitherto untouched sections. However, analyzing the events between the two world wars prevents us from looking at just flesh without blood.

The humiliating Treaty of Versailles and the resulting discontent and violation of dignity of the German masses was the prime reason for the rise of the dictator. The lack of empathy in the hearts of the Allied Powers and the tussle for German territories pushed the world to the brink in 1920 itself. The next two decades was the blooming of the plant who'se seed had been sown already in 1920.

Such a multidimensional questioning and analysis of all aspects of the truth of all stakeholders is essential for holistic understanding of the situation. However, is just debate and discussion the end in itself? Can just shaking the truth lead to any tangible outcomes?

This leads to the philosophy of Aurelius who asks us to not just question but also act on the existing consensus already gained by previous bouts of inquisition. This is so because truth and ethics are subjective and depend on the situation. One of the prime examples was the advent of extremists on the stage of national movement and their shunning of the moderate's truth that masses werent capable of participating in the freedom struggle. A keener observation tells us that both extremists and moderates acted upon their respective perceptions and both made valuable contributions to our freedom struggle.

Inspite of this knowledge, this is still a half baked cake without analyzing what is stopping the individual from questioning the truth and exhibiting a spirit of inquiry. This is because nature has placed mankind under two sovereign masters - pain and pleasure. The pleasure of psychological inertia and avoidance of the pain of effort to change gives the human the right dosage of the reward chemical dopamine to stick to the accepted adage and accept it without any cross-examination.

This is the prime reason why leaders are few and followers in plenty. The reason is that accepting the societal norms as the truth without questioning preserves our sanity and protects us from social ostracization. Yet, the names we remember today are of those who questioned the immoral standards of society like Sati and became the trailblazer of modern rationality which places individual rights at the core.

Embibing that level of rational outlook requires upholding our fundamental duty of instilling scientific temper in ourselves, a difficult task in the world where whatsapp forwards are considered the sources of truth and fake news like chip in ₹2000 notes is promoted by mainstream media.

Next in line comes the duty to understand fundamental truths about rationality as told by Nietzsche in his idea of the Stoic Superman. He tells that change is the only constant and that any truth always flows from the philosophies of realpolitik as in the international arena. Shaking the truth requires a blend of realism and idealism to not get caught in the utopian idealism.

Once we accept the actionable truth, the next task is to refine it via debate and inviting new ideas just like Parliament does with various bills, feedback and revision coupled with action and implementation of the accepted consensus. This would have helped to protect Galileo from being banished to the gallows and would have given him the opportunity to contribute more to the benefit of humanity.