12. Constitutional developments in British India were reactive rather than genuine efforts for good governance. Examine. (15 marks, 250 words)
Vikas, AIR 27, 2025
Britishers introduced constitutional reforms from time to time as per the needs of time, for e.g. Charter Acts.
Reactive nature of these developments:
1. Passed after major struggles by Indians like 1857 revolt led to Government of India Act 1858. 2. Used to pacify dissent among Indians and their opposition to british rule, for e.g. 1892 Indian Councils Act in reaction to INC's movement. 3. Carrot & stick policy -> Britishers used constitutional reforms as a carrot for moderates and used violence & as a stick to suppress opposition. 4. Repression – conciliation-suppression Strategy -> where constitutional reforms were used a means to create differences among nationalists to repress the movement by divisions. 5. Hollow nature of the constitutional developments due to no substantive measures, for e.g. 1919 and 1935 reforms were reforms 'in face value' only. 6. No proper follow up on the reforms like 1935 Government of India act never got implemented. 7. Negligible Indian participation to exclude priorities of Indians and continue the perpetuation of British empire, for e.g. opposition to all white Simon commission. 8. Divide & Rule policy -> where the constitutional reforms were used to create divisions in society, e.g. separate electorates in 1909 Indian Council Act.
Progressiveness was also there in some of the laws of Britishers:
1. Educational & socio cultural reforms like in Charter Act 1853 and wood's despatch. 2. Responsible Government, Bicameralism etc. in 1919 Government of India Act. 3. Federalism, federal court, RBI, provincial autonomy etc. in Government of India Act 1835. 4. Minority safeguards and condition of marginalized sections like dalits in Round Table Conference etc.
Britishers laws were for the benefit of British interests but they also helped in constitutional development and laid cornerstone among Indians.