Topper Copies

What is Structuralist and Horizontalist Theory of endogenous money supply?

Ruhani, AIR 5, 2023

Structuralist and Horizontalist models of endogenous money supply state that bank lending drives money and that the latter is endogenously determined.

Both these models form a part of Post-Keynesian theory of money supply which demolish the arguments of monetarism that money supply is exogenous.

HORIZONTALIST THEORY -> has been given by Moore(1988) -> It consists of 6 equations:

1) iL = (1+m) iF Loan rate = markup of Bank over Repo rate

2) Ld = L(iL, ....) Demand for loan

3) Ls = Ld

4) Bank's Balance Sheet Equation: Assets = Liabilities L + R = M + E Loans + Reserves = Deposits + Bank's Equity

5) R = kM Reserves = CRR × Deposit

6) H = R High-powered money = Bank reserves

[a graph of roi against Loan and M: a horizontal line at iF intersecting downward-sloping Ld/Ls curves at Lo, with monetary base H shown horizontal and M0 marked on the M axis]

Thus, at iF (repo rate), monetary base is horizontal.

Banks set iL as a markup over iF. At iL, loan supply schedule is horizontal, as banks are willing to supply any demand for loans at this rate.

Thus, equilibrium amount of loans, Lo are determined, which further determine M. Thus, loans determine deposits and thus, money supply as per the Horizontalist model.

The Structuralist model includes many more aspects like risk-aversion of banks, etc. to make the horizontalist model more realistic.