Discuss the significance of the Supreme Court's recent judgement upholding Section 6A of the Citizenship Act, 1955, in the context of the Assam Accord. What is its larger implication for the region?
Shubham Singh, AIR 21, 2025
Section 6A was inserted into Citizenship Act 1955 as a result of Assam Accord which was signed in 1985 between Rajiv Gandhi Govt., Assam Govt. and leadership of AASU & AAGSP to address the issue of illegal immigration in Assam.
SC verdict on Section 6A 1. Does not violate A.14 despite having specific cutoff date for Assam only as it is a specific legislation to address specific problem 2. Does not violate A.29 of indigenous Assamese as presence of other ethnic groups does not prevent Assamese from preserving their culture & heritage 3. On violation of A.326: SC has held that adult franchise under A.326 does not give right to any community to maintain electoral majority
Significance of the verdict 1. Clears the way for NRC which was held recently with 1st Jan 1966 and 25th March 1971 as cutoffs 2. Can tone down the resentment against the Assam accord among certain segments such as ULFA 3. Admits that illegal immigration is a menace
Implication +ve 1. NRC process would move forward 2. Benchmark to address the issue of illegal immigration state-wise 3. Address the issue of demographic shift in certain pockets
-ve 1. No deportation agreement with Bangladesh may create diplomatic issue 2. Lack of detention centers, foreigners tribunal 3. Clash with the cut-off date of December 2014 in Citizenship Amendment Act 2016 4. Large no. of "stateless people"
Addressing the menace of illegal immigration also requires comprehensive border management to address "flow".