क्या आपको लगता है कि समान नागरिक संहिता भारतीय समाज में धार्मिक बहुलवाद और सांस्कृतिक भिन्नता के विचार का खंडन करती है? / Do you think the Uniform Civil Code contradicts the idea of religious pluralism and cultural differences in Indian society?
Nisar Dishant Amrutlal, AIR 19, 2025
Article 44 of DPSPs guide that the State should have 'Uniform Civil Code' (UCC). It means 'Common personal laws' and thus equality.
Need, as it doesn't contradict
1. Religion in personal sphere not impacted, only aim for common laws in marriage, property etc. 2. Against discriminatory practices and women empowerment of women, downtrodden: Triple Talaq, Genital mutilation etc. 3. Create equal society where women have equal property share 4. Reduce pendency on Courts and helps in justice 5. Celebrates pluralism by reducing discrimination
Contradicts
1. law commission Report says UCC not feasible and not desirable 2. Common laws exist: Special marriage act 1956 3. Personal laws are by virtue of multiculturalism not falls to 'differential right's' to minorities 4. State's intervention in personal sphere against tolerance, diversity
However, UCC is needed to ensure society gets acess to it's best potential.
Uttarakhand, Goa's UCC can serve as guide.
Through dialogues, and decentralised approach, common UCC can be created.
Even SC in 'Sarla Mudgal' case has called for 'Just UCC'