Topper Copies

The Supreme Court in Davinder Singh v. State of Punjab upheld sub-categorisation of SC/ST communities for reservation. Discuss whether this judgement makes reservation fair or unfair, and suggest a way forward.

Kanika Anabh

The Supreme Court in Davinder Singh v/s State of Punjab upheld that there should be subcategorisation of SC/ST communities.

Judgement affecting fairness of reservation benefits

Makes it Unfair

1. Overturns E. Chinniah judgement, stating SCs are a 'homogenous group' 2. Creates subdivisions among the SC, ST groups, can further lead to resentment 3. Even economically sound SCs may face discrimination and stigma, judgement does not acknowledge this 4. The subdivisions can be arbitrary, high chances of exclusion errors

Makes it Fair

1. Allows reservation to be equally distributed, presently utilised by less than 10% of their population 2. Fair approach of making way for the most backward, Antyodaya philosophy 3. Sets logical parameters, e.g. child of SC civil servant can't be equal to a child of poor SC farmer in village 4. Reflects ground reality, e.g. in dhobi community 146 out of 10,000 get higher education which is 1 out of 10,000 for [text lost] community of Bihar 5. Makes the reservation policy more equitable 6. Increasing accessibility to posts, e.g. in Tamil Nadu some communities have 60% of jobs even though their population is low

Way Forward

1. Ensuring an independent commission to set criteria for subcategorisation 2. Subcategorisation must be made on absolutely empirical basis 3. Preventing the politicisation of any such subcategorisation move 4. The idea of limiting reservation till one generation can also be explored

This will help in the advancement of the 'Mahadalits' of India.