Topper Copies

Patriotism encourages ethical questioning, while nationalism often suppresses it. Discuss this statement in light of the formation of political attitudes during high-pressure national events. How can individuals develop moral attitudes that balance national interest with ethical reasoning?

Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025

"Support your country at all times, while your government when it deserves" - Mark Twain

The statement becomes imperative in times like Op Sindoor → whether citizens question information or blindly accept.

Political Attitude in High pressure events

1. Political bias may cloud objective assessment 2. Difference between truth and narrative as fake news increasing

Discussion of statement

1. True meaning of being patriotic is about questioning 2. Love for country doesn't mean can't question 3. Surrender of rationality may lead to national decay. Healthy criticism blown out of context (eg Uri Attack political situation) 4. Unity needed in high stress situations (eg All party meeting in wars)

Individual: developing moral attitude which balances both.

2. "Gandhiji's idea → feel everyone's breeze, don't get blown" 3. "Wisdom lies in knowing what to stick and what to forgo" [Core values] → no question, other ideas criticised 4.

Thus apply universal values (eg Kant → categorical imperative)

If there is jingoism and blind obedience, either it is suppression [China] or psychophancy. In both cases it is the beginning of end of nations and civilisation. "The art of question is universal but its application is contextual."